We present experiments on second-harmonic generation from arrays of magnetic split-ring resonators and arrays of complementary split-ring resonators. In both cases, the fundamental resonance is excited by the incident femtosecond laser pulses under normal incidence, leading to comparably strong second-harmonic signals. These findings are discussed in terms of Babinet's principle and in terms of a recently developed microscopic classical theory that leads to good agreement regarding the relative and the absolute nonlinear signal strengths. The hydrodynamic convective contribution is found to be the dominant source of secondharmonic generation-in contrast to a previous assignment [Science 313, 502 (2006) Photonic metamaterials are an emerging class of tailored composite effective materials that can provide interesting optical properties such as, e.g., magnetism at elevated frequencies [1][2][3] or an enhanced nonlinear optical response [1,[4][5][6][7][8][9][10]. Indeed, in a series of recent experiments [6-8], we have observed second-harmonic generation (SHG) from planar arrays of gold split-ring resonators (SRRs) exhibiting a pronounced magnetic-dipole response. In essence, a SRR is an almost closed loop of a metal wire that can be viewed as a subwavelength electromagnet in which the incident light field induces a circulating oscillating electrical current, leading to a local magnetic field (magnetic-dipole moment) perpendicular to the SRR plane. It has been found [7,8] that arrays of gold "T"s show SHG that is 2 orders of magnitude smaller than that of the gold SRR arrays-despite the facts that the "T"s also exhibit a resonance at the incident fundamental laser frequency and that they are also known to exhibit pronounced local field enhancements.In this Letter, we aim at further clarifying the underlying mechanism. First, we present new experimental results on complementary split-ring resonators (CSRRs), i.e., SRRs in which the metal in the sample plane is replaced by air and vice versa. According to the generalized Babinet's principle [11,12], magnetic and electric fields are interchanged with respect to SRR (precisely, E ជ ͑r ជ , t͒ ↔ −c 0 B ជ ͑r ជ , t͒). Hence, the magnetic-dipole moment of the SRR turns into an electric-dipole moment of the CSRR, allowing us to investigate whether the magnetic-dipole moment is crucial for efficient SHG. Second, we compare these experimental results with numerical calculations based on a recently developed microscopic classical theory of the metal-based metamaterial optical nonlinearities [13].The samples for our experiments are fabricated by standard electron-beam lithography, electron-beam evaporation of the 25 nm thick gold layer onto a glass substrate coated with a 5 nm thin film of indium tin oxide (ITO), and subsequent lift-off. Details can be found in [14]. The SRR and the CSRR arrays have been fabricated on two different glass substrates, however, with closely similar processing steps. The footprint of each array is 100 m ϫ 100 m. Electron micrographs of representativ...