The goals of this study were to investigate muscle fatigue in patients with multiple sclerosis (MS), and to determine the relationships between muscle fatigue, clinical status, and perceived fatigue. The fatigability of the anterior tibial muscle was quantitated in patients and controls during 9 min of intermittent stimulation (used to eliminate central sources of muscle fatigue). During exercise, the decline in tetanic force, phosphocreatine, and intracellular pH was greater in patients than in controls. The compound muscle action potential amplitude did not decrease during exercise, indicating that there was no failure of neuromuscular transmission during fatigue. Thus, the excessive fatigue in MS developed from sources beyond the muscle memberane. Following exercise, the recovery of tetanic force was delayed in patients (a pattern that suggests abnormal excitation-contraction coupling), whereas the recovery of metabolites was complete in both groups. Muscular fatigue was correlated with clinical disability but not with perceived fatigue. These results suggests that fatigue in MS has both central (perception, upper motor neuron dysfunction) and peripheral (impaired metabolism and excitation-contraction coupling) components.
Keywordsexercise; excitation-contraction coupling; metabolism; magnetic resonance spectroscopy Fatigue is a common and frequently disabling symptom in patients with multiple sclerosis (MS). 11 However, the mechanisms of fatigue in MS remain unclear. 5,28 Central sources of fatigue might well be a factor for MS patients, and could involve at least two different mechanisms. First, recruitment of alpha motor neurons is impaired because of lesions in corticospinal pathways. 33 Second, reaction times are delayed and cognitive activity is abnormal in many patients with MS, suggesting that the processes involved in preparing for and initiating motor responses are also affected. 34,35 Previous studies have shown that peripheral sources of fatigue are also important in spastic muscles. 24,29 Lenman et al. suggested secondary changes in spastic muscles are similar to those of immobilization and disuse. 24 In another study of a small number of patients with various types of spastic paraparesis, greater changes in energy metabolites accompanied the excessive muscle fatigue observed in patients compared to controls, which suggested that intramuscular factors may contribute to fatigue in spastic paraparesis. 29 Recently, in patients with MS, we have observed both reduced muscular oxidative capacity, 19 Therefore, the main objective of this study was to investigate muscle fatigue in MS patients, and to determine the extent to which muscle fatigue was related to clinical status and perceived fatigue. We examined fatigue in a group of MS patients and in healthy control subjects by measuring muscle force, activation, and energy metabolism during electrical stimulation of the anterior tibial muscle. By using stimulated contractions to induce muscle fatigue, central factors were eliminated and the per...