Direct seawater electrolysis is a promising approach to producing green hydrogen in water-scarce environments using renewable energy. However, the undesirable chlorine evolution reaction and hypochlorite evolution reaction compete with the desired oxygen evolution reaction (OER) at the anode electrocatalyst. This issue is most pronounced in unbuffered pH-neutral solutions due to local acidification resulting from the OER. To overcome this challenge, this study provides a comprehensive evaluation of the use of silicon oxide (SiO x ) and titanium oxide (TiO x ) nanoscale overlayers coated on metallic ruthenium (Ru) and ruthenium oxide (RuO x ) thin film electrodes and their ability to block chloride ions from reaching active sites during operation in an unbuffered 0.6 M NaCl electrolyte. Using a combination of (electro)analytical techniques, encapsulated RuO x anodes are shown to effectively suppress Cl − transport to buried catalyst active sites while allowing for the desired OER to occur, leading to increases in OER faradaic efficiency at moderate overpotentials. Evidence for the ability of SiO x overlayers to block Cl − ions from reaching the active buried interface was obtained by monitoring the ν(O−H) stretching mode of OH adsorbates using in situ Raman spectroscopy. This study also reports trade-offs between the activity, selectivity, and stability of bare and encapsulated Ru and RuO x electrocatalysts, finding that the magnitude of these trade-offs strongly depends on the complex interplay between electrode architecture, material properties, and catalytic performance, especially in unbuffered pH-neutral seawater.