Negative findings in electronic health records and biomedical ontologies: A realist approach

Abstract

PURPOSE-A substantial fraction of the observations made by clinicians and entered into patient records are expressed by means of negation or by using terms which contain negative qualifiers (as in "absence of pulse" or "surgical procedure not performed"). This seems at first sight to present problems for ontologies, terminologies and data repositories that adhere to a realist view and thus reject any reference to putative non-existing entities. Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) and Referent Tracking (RT) are examples of such paradigms. The purpose of the research here described was to test a proposal to capture negative findings in electronic health record systems based on BFO and RT.METHODS-We analysed a series of negative findings encountered in 748 sentences taken from 41 patient charts. We classified the phenomena described in terms of the various top-level categories and relations defined in BFO, taking into account the role of negation in the corresponding descriptions. We also studied terms from SNOMED-CT containing one or other form of negation. We then explored ways to represent the described phenomena by means of the types of representational units available to realist ontologies such as BFO.RESULTS-We introduced a new family of 'lacks' relations into the OBO Relation Ontology. The relation lacks_part, for example, defined in terms of the positive relation part_of, holds between a particular p and a universal U when p has no instance of U as part. Since p and U both exist, assertions involving 'lacks_part' and its cognates meet the requirements of positivity.CONCLUSION-By expanding the OBO Relation Ontology, we were able to accommodate nearly all occurrences of negative findings in the sample studied.

Evaluation of voice-based data entry to an electronic health record system for dentistry

“…Standardized terminologies contain many terms in which some mistakes or ambiguities can be found [19]. We experimentally confirmed that the data collection using the Lifetime Dent Cross controlled by the voice or the keyboard is precise and offers the same degree of freedom as the paper dental card.…”

A biomedical research permissions ontology

“…In fact it is a requirement for reimbursement by the US Medicare and Medicaid regulations that patient records contain “abnormal and relevant negative findings” [6]. Ceusters, Elkin & Smith suggest that to adequately accommodate the variety of negation and negative findings required in health documentation that a health ontology provide a “lacks or lacks part of” relationship instantiated in an appropriately expressive medical ontology [7]. As a permissions ontology for use in research will need to address both ambiguously named and / or partially defined permission for use of data or tissue use in the future, it is a consideration of the project as to how to adequately express permissions that are explicitly not given as differentiated from those that are not expressly asked.…”

Towards an ontological representation of resistance: The case of MRSA

“…In BFO-based ontologies, the lacks relation can be used to capture negative findings at one scale of biological description while avoiding the problems of using negative predicates or characteristics [4]. In describing resistance, we will need to say that independent continuants of a certain type do not exhibit a dependent continuant of a certain type.…”