Negotiating the ‘real’ in ‘reality shows’: production side discourses between deconstruction and reconstruction

Abstract

In this study, we set out to elaborate configurations of the 'real' and 'authentic' in the discourses of program makers and participants of 'reality shows'. This production side perspective has more often been the object, rather than the subject, in the debate. We develop our argument through a theoretically informed discussion at the intersection of cultural and documentary studies. Our analysis proceeds through a thematic content analysis of 39 semi-structured, in-depth interviews with 14 television professionals and 25 participants involved in the production of formats belonging to various subgenres, all with a border-crossing circulation. The analysis demonstrates that when gauging 'the real' in 'reality shows', participants and program makers do not subscribe to a 'naïve realistic' celebration, as the 'reality TV' denominator may suggest, yet, nonetheless still strongly invest in a sense of the 'real' or 'authentic'. As such, they engage in a sophisticated, dynamic and, so it could be argued, strategic shifting to-and-fro deconstructive and reconstructive positions. What ensues from this dialog between deconstruction and reconstruction is a conception of the 'reality show' as a nodal point of the multiple and ever-evolving configurations of the 'real' and the 'authentic' in a reflexive, media-savvy culture.

Brexit, paz y Trump: enseñanzas para los economistas

“…En estos programas el elemento "real" se da principalmente por la capacidad de los concursantes de presentar una personalidad que se conecta emocionalmente con los espectadores. Un buen participante es aquel al que el público puede amar u odiar pero con el cual tiene una conexión fuerte (Mast, 2016). El personaje que transmitió Trump durante su candidatura fue precisamente eso, y logró una conexión emocional con buena parte del público de votantes en estados clave 10 .…”

The Male Gaze or Male Gays? From Romance to Bromance through Performances of Gender and Sexuality by two of Love Island’s Favourite Characters

“…There is a body of scholarship which questions what is 'real' and 'authentic' in reality television shows (e.g. Mast, 2016), appreciating that performance can be curated by both producers and the characters of these shows. For instance, Skeggs (2009:626) discusses the "self-performance" of individuals on reality television.…”

An (un)romantic journey: Authentic performance in a Chinese dating show

“…Reality television has become a standard provision in today television which format, content and ideology have kept changing over three generations (Kavka, 2012). Despite great variations in theme and format (Mast, 2016), it has once been stated that reality television refers to unscripted entertainment involving ordinary people (Tincknell & Raghuram, 2002). The two keywords here, ‘unscripted’ and ‘ordinary’, are both closely related to a sense of authenticity.…”

“…To programme makers, reality television was neither fictional nor purely factual. Rather, producers believed that they were handling a kind of ‘managed reality’, which was a result of the interaction of format, simulation and narrative (Mast, 2016). An informant argued that reality television was about anticipation: they were predicting what would reasonably happen as events unfolded.…”

“…Mast (2016) found that producers understood their actions in reality shows as anticipating reality rather than manipulating it. Their anticipation led them to make various arrangements on stage accordingly, including the order of appearance of the male contestants, the numbered positions allotted to the female participants and even the ones to be chosen.…”