“…The two maps help us identify clusters of keywords that cooccurred, which are then used to extract the related topic and engineering discipline as summarized in Table 1 for PBL and in Table 2 for VR along with a list of sample references. [8], [9]- [13], [14], [15] Mechanical Engineering Machine concepts, Finite element analysis, HVAC, Fluid and Thermal design, Thermodynamics, Dynamic [16], [17]- [19], [20], [21], [22] Aerospace Engineering Aerospace research materials [23] Computer Engineering Concepts of CE (generic) [24] Biosystem Engineering Biosystem engineering concepts (generic) [25] [34], [35], [36] Mechanical Engineering Wind tunnels, Prototype vehicles, Robot system, physical experiment, Virtual dynamic laboratory, Uncertainty analysis [37], [38], [39] Electrical Engineering Nanotechnology, VR simulation [40] Biomedical Engineering Simulations in biosystems [41] (a) Project-/problem-based learning. , we can see that PBL is used much more frequently than VR in engineering education.…”