Much of the forage produced in the subhumid areas of the USA is from cool‐season species, which mature and become dormant in early summer. This results in minimal forage produced in mid‐ to late summer, a time referred to as a “summer slump.” ‘Red River’ crabgrass [Digitaria ciliaris (Retz) Koel.] is a productive warm‐season annual that can fill this void, but optimum N fertilizer management for this species is unknown in much of the eastern plains of the USA. We tested N rates of 0, 50, 100, 150, and 200 lb N/acre from two sources, urea and ammonium nitrate, applied as single or split applications, on two cuttings during two years that contrasted in rainfall. A yield plateau was reached just above 100 lb N/acre both years, although yield was 2× higher in the moist year. However, forage fertilized with more than 100 lb N/acre generally had a higher N concentration than forage that received less N. Split application often resulted in less forage with a lower N concentration in the first cutting, but more in the second cutting than a single N application. Responses to N source were small, with application as ammonium nitrate yielding more than urea only in the second cutting at lower N rates.