We present an experiment that probes polariton quantum correlations by exploiting quantum complementarity. Specifically, we find that polaritons in two distinct idler-modes interfere if and only if they share the same signal-mode so that "which-way" information cannot be gathered. The experimental results prove the existence of polariton pair correlations that store the "which-way" information. This interpretation is confirmed by a theoretical analysis of the measured interference visibility in terms of quantum Langevin equations.PACS numbers: 71.36.+c, 42.50.Dv, 71.35.Gg, 42.50.Nn Quantum complementarity is the essential feature distinguishing quantum from classical physics [1]. When two physical observables are complementary, the precise knowledge of one of them makes the other unpredictable. The most known manifestation of this principle is the property of quantum-mechanical entities to behave either as particles or as waves under different experimental conditions. The link between quantum correlations, quantum nonlocality and Bohr's complementarity principle was established in a series of "which-way" experiments [2,3,4,5], in which the underlying idea is the same as in Young's double-slit experiment. Due to its wave-like nature, a particle can be set up to travel along a quantum superposition of two different paths, resulting in an interference pattern. If however a "which-way" detector is employed to determine the particle's path, the particlelike behavior takes over and an interference pattern is no longer observed. These experiments have brought evidence that the loss of interference is not necessarily a consequence of the back action of a measurement process [5]. Quantum complementarity is rather an inherent property of a system, enforced by quantum correlations [1]. We investigate this manifestation of quantum mechanics for cavity polaritons. Polaritons in semiconductor microcavities are hybrid quasiparticles consisting of a superposition of cavity photons and two-dimensional collective electronic excitations (excitons) in an embedded quantum well [6]. Owing to their mutual Coulomb interaction, pump polaritons generated by a resonant optical excitation can scatter resonantly into pairs of polaritons (signal and idler) [7,8,9,10,11,12,13]. In the low excitation limit, the polariton parametric scattering is a spontaneous process driven by vacuum-field fluctuations [9] whereas, already at moderate excitation intensity, it displays self-stimulation [12].