Novel ethanol production using biomass preprocessing to increase ethanol yield and reduce overall costs

Abstract

Background: Ethanol biorefineries need to lower their overall production costs to become economically feasible. Two strategies to achieve this are to reduce costs by using cheaper feedstocks or to increase the ethanol production yield. Low-cost feedstocks usually have high non-structural components (NSC) content, therefore a new process is necessary to accommodate these feedstocks and overcome the negative effects of NSC. This study developed a novel ethanol biorefinery process including a biomass preprocessing step that enabled the use of lower-cost feedstocks while improving ethanol production without detoxification (overliming). Two types of poplar feedstocks were used, low-quality whole-tree chips (WTC) and high-quality clean pulp chips (CPC), to determine if the proposed process is effective while using feedstocks with different NSC contents.Results: Technical assessment showed that acidic preprocessing increased the monomeric sugar recovery of WTC from 73.2% (untreated) to 87.5% due to reduced buffering capacity of poplar, improved sugar solubilization during pretreatment, and better enzymatic hydrolysis conversion. Preprocessing alone significantly improved the fermentability of the liquid fraction from 1-2% to 49-56% for both feedstocks, while overliming improved it to 45%. Consequently, it was proposed that preprocessing can substitute for the detoxification step. The economic assessment revealed that using poplar WTC via the new process increased annual ethanol production of 10.5 million liters when compared to using CPC via overliming (base case scenario). Also, savings in total operating costs were about $10 million per year when using cheaper poplar WTC instead of CPC, and by using recycled water for preprocessing lowered its total operating costs by 45-fold.Conclusions: The novel process developed in this study was successful in increasing ethanol production while decreasing overall costs, thus facilitating the feasibility of lignocellulosic ethanol biorefineries. Key factors to achieving this outcome included substituting overliming by preprocessing, enabling the use of lower-quality feedstock, increasing monomeric sugar recovery and ethanol fermentation yield, and using recycled water for preprocessing. In addition, preprocessing enabled the implementation of an evaporator-combustor downstream design, resulting in a low-loading waste stream that can be treated in a wastewater treatment plant with a simple configuration.

The US bioeconomy at the intersection of technology, policy, and education

“…A potential solution to this problem is to subject low-quality feedstocks to additional preprocessing steps aiming to minimize the negative effects of unwanted components and increase overall production yields. 43 The cost-effectiveness of biomass conversion could be increased by focusing on maximizing biomass use. This could be accomplished by expanding the product portfolio of any given biorefinery.…”

“…For example, using low‐cost biomass feedstocks with inferior quality (i.e., high content of unwanted components) can help decrease production costs but will result in lower production yields. A potential solution to this problem is to subject low‐quality feedstocks to additional preprocessing steps aiming to minimize the negative effects of unwanted components and increase overall production yields 43 …”