Damaged support bores due to wear and ovality can be critical for a machine and its operation, in addition to representing a safety problem and risk of pin breakage. It can be a costly operation to perform the required repairs in between planned service periods, especially because of the unplanned down time. A joint with a standard cylindrical pin will often experience wear and ovality in the support bore surfaces, and at some point, repairs will have to be performed. This study investigates and compares five options when a joint with a cylindrical pin has reached a severe level of wear and ovality, outside its planned service stop. The work involved testing the viability of 3D scanning of the damaged bore surface, 3D printing of a metal bushing, and inserting the bushing into the damaged joint. In addition, two pin solutions, i.e., a standard cylindrical pin and an expanding pin type, were installed into the repaired joint, loaded, and the strain on the pin ends close to the supports was measured. For the sake of comparison, the supports had both smooth circular bore and severe wear and ovality. It was concluded that it is possible to produce and install the 3D-printed bushing insert without major problems; the insert had satisfactory capability during test loading, and it most probably represents a good solution when it comes to the reduction in unwanted downtime during unplanned repairs of damaged joints.