The iron and acid-labile sulfide contents and the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) properties of hydrogenase I (bidirectional) and hydrogenase II (uptake) of Clostridiumpasteurianum (strain W5) have been determined on the basis of quantitative amino acid analyses. The iron and acid-labile sulfide values are approximately 20 and 18 atoms per molecule of hydrogenase I and 14 and 11 atoms per molecule of hydrogenase II, respectively. These amounts are substantially greater than previously reported values, which relied on protein concentration determined by calorimetric assay. The oxidized hydrogenases exhibit unusual EPR signals that originate from a novel type of iron-sulfur center, termed the hydrogenase or H cluster, which covalently binds the inhibitor CO. This EPR signal represents approximately one unpaired electron per molecule in each enzyme with and without bound CO, which is consistent with the presence of one oxidized H cluster (S = 1/2) per enzyme molecule. The two enzymes also contain ferredoxin-type four-iron centers or F clusters. The EPR signals from the F clusters observed in the reduced forms ofhydrogenase I and hydrogenase II account for approximately four and one unpaired electron per molecule, respectively. We conclude from the iron determinations and the EPR results, together with a reevaluation of previous spectroscopic data, that in both hydrogenases the H cluster probably comprises six iron atoms. Mechanistic models of the two hydrogenases are presented that account for their cluster compositions and the dramatic differences in their catalytic activities.Hydrogenases catalyze the reversible activation of molecular H2 according to the reaction:They are widely distributed in bacteria and are a very heterogeneous group of enzymes: their only common feature is that they are iron-sulfur proteins and the majority also contain nickel (1-4). The anaerobic N2-fixing bacterium Clostridium pasteurianum is so far unique in that it contains two hydrogenases that lack nickel. Hydrogenase I (bidirectional) catalyzes both H2 evolution and H2 oxidation at extremely high rates in vitro, whereas hydrogenase II preferentially catalyzes H2 oxidation (5)(6)(7)(8) (7,(9)(10)(11)(12). A combination of EPR and 1H, 13C, and 57Fe electron nuclear double resonance spectroscopy (ENDOR) has shown that in both hydrogenases the H cluster contains two types of iron atoms and covalently binds CO, a potent inhibitor, without cluster destruction (13,14). Subsequent Mossbauer analysis of hydrogenase II showed that its H cluster contains two types of iron atoms in a 2:1 ratio and was '40% of the total iron (15). Therefore, it was concluded that the H cluster is a three-iron cluster (15). Thus, on the basis of these results and the determined iron concentrations, hydrogenase II was thought to contain 7 iron atoms per molecule (one H and one F cluster), and hydrogenase I, 11 iron atoms per molecule (one H and two F clusters). However, the proposed cluster compositions of the clostridial hydrogenases are not consisten...