Landscape shapes record processes of formation. In particular, fluvial processes typically exhibit V-shaped profiles with steep slopes, whereas glacial processes carve U-shaped valleys with variable slopes and overdeepenings (MacGregor et al., 2000;Prasicek et al., 2014). Overdeepened valleys are those with depths extending below fluvial base level (Preusser et al., 2010) and are key elements of glacial landscapes where warm-bed conditions exist(ed) (e.g., Benn & Evans, 1998;Cook & Swift, 2012). Such valleys are characterized by closed topographic depressions and are commonly eroded several hundred meters below the base level (Fiebig et al., 2010;Menzies, 1995;Preusser et al., 2010). Overdeepening on basement is unknown in canyons carved exclusively by fluvial processes (Cook & Swift, 2012;Huuse & Lykke-Andersen, 2000;Linton, 1963); rather, overdeepenings are considered "unambiguous features of glacially sculpted landscapes" (Pomper et al., 2017). Overdeepening occurs in cirques, valley outlets of alpine glaciers, and fjords and valleys draining continental ice sheets, related to perturbations in the bed that amplify the action of high-pressure meltwater (Hooke, 1991).Seismic imaging has been widely used to characterize Quaternary glacial valleys and, together with drilling and other subsurface data, has demonstrated the distinctive propensity for glacial processes to produce not Abstract Unaweep Canyon (Uncompahgre Plateau, Colorado) represents an enigmatic landscape with a complex evolution. Interpretations for its origin have ranged from ancestral fluvial erosion in the late Cenozoic to glacial erosion in the Paleozoic, or some combination thereof, with significant implications for global climatic and large-scale tectonic reconstructions. To address the conflicting interpretations, we acquired a high-resolution seismic reflection profile to investigate the depth, structure, and sedimentary infill in the canyon. The data set is further complemented with an electrical resistivity survey. Integrated with other geophysical and geological data, the results show an overdeepened Precambrian basement with transverse U shape and support the hypothesis of a pre-Quaternary glacial origin. Our data constitute the first detailed image of a buried pre-Quaternary glacial valley in North America; if substantiated with core studies, these results have far-reaching implications for our understanding of global ice houses as well as the tectonic conditions, enabling preservation of such systems.
Plain Language SummaryThe shape of valleys depends on the processes that created them.Broad valleys with the transverse shape of a "U" are distinct signs of glaciers, which carved the valley in the bedrock. Since old valleys are filled up with sediments, we need geophysical tools to image their structure in the buried subsurface. Using such tools, we have found a buried U-shaped valley in western Colorado. Since we know from other observations that there were no glaciers in this specific location in the last ice age, the valley must have ...