Organizational Production of Self-Censorship in the Hong Kong Media

Abstract

Media self-censorship refers to nonexternally compelled acts committed by media organizations aiming to avoid offending power holders such as the government, advertisers, and major business corporations. While self-censorship constitutes a major threat to press freedom in Hong Kong under China, recent studies have shown that Hong Kong journalists have maintained a strong sense of professionalism. The coexistence of professionalism and self-censorship poses important challenges to news organizations: How is self-censorship effected as professionalism does not favor its practice? How can news organizations minimize the conflicts between self-censorship and professionalism so that news operations will remain stable, smooth, and efficient? Drawing on the literature on newsroom social control, we tackle the above questions by focusing on the internal structure of and the interactive dynamics within newsrooms. Methodologically, this study draws on both representative survey and in-depth interview data. It is found that self-censorship is effected through selective positioning and assignment, observational learning of tacit rules, the giving of ambiguous orders, and the use of professional or technical reasons to justify questionable news decisions. Meanwhile, some journalists also developed their own operational tactics to resist what they perceived as self-censorship attempts. The theoretical implications of the findings are discussed.

Understanding the Psychological Process of Avoidance-Based Self-Regulation on Facebook

“…ABSR constituted the mean of these three items. The notion of caution has been associated with self-censorship in prior work 32 and allows for a measure of the most major form of censorship that which occurs before information is communicated. 12,16…”

Digital media use and participation leadership in social protests: The case of Tiananmen commemoration in Hong Kong

“…Nevertheless, traditional news media in Hong Kong also suffer from the problem of self-censorship (Lee and Chan, 2009). While the news media cannot totally ignore the large-scale rally and the issue of Tiananmen, the media are often perceived to have toned down the coverage in fear of enraging China.…”

“…One plausible reason is that the negative relationship between online political communication and news consumption is generated by a critical attitude toward the performance of the mainstream media in Hong Kong. Older adults may be more perceptive about the problem of self-censorship in the mainstream media (Lee and Chan, 2009). Hence their online political communication may become articulated with a sense of dissatisfaction with and lower levels of consumption of traditional news media.…”

Mass Media, Journalism, Society, and Culture

“…Even journalists with a sense of being autonomous will have to conform to the rules of the organization where they work, which are often tacit rules or ambiguous requests by superiors, like asking for a "balanced" view. Self-censorship in undemocratic societies can be very elusive with various informal mechanisms when news organizations need their workers to follow specifi c approaches when covering a story, but professional journalists also are often able to evade these mechanisms (Lee and Chan 2009 ).…”