Organizing Awareness and Increasing Emotion Regulation: Revising Chair Work in Emotion-Focused Therapy for Borderline Personality Disorder

Abstract

Emotion-focused therapy (EFT) is an empirically supported treatment that may have potential as a stage-two treatment for borderline personality disorder (BPD). Specific aspects of BPD--the tendency to experience fluctuating self-states; weakness in meta-cognitive or reflective functioning; and the tendency for self-states to be organized by presently occurring interpersonal processes--present challenges to applying some EFT interventions with this population. In particular, even within a highly attuned, validating and accepting empathic relationship, clients with BPD may have difficulty with the usual manualizations of chair work interventions. This is because these interventions often employ polarization and intensification of experience in order to activate adaptive alternate emotional resources and self organizations. For the client with borderline personality disorder, these interventions may be counter-productive, emotionally dysregulating and disorganizing. EFT chair work, however, also has the potential to provide structure to the borderline clients experience of self, to stimulate metacognitive awareness, provide an alive experience of the process of polarization, attenuate emotional activation, and increase the experience of self-coherence. This article describes the development of stepwise approximations of EFT two-chair intervention for self-critical splits. It outlines potential stages of two-chair work as well as intervention principles important for productive chair work with this population. The EFT change principles of awareness, expression regulation, reflection, transformation, and corrective experience still centrally apply. However, several additional strategies are discussed to scaffold clients' capacity to both experience and regulate emotion.

Interpersonal processes affecting early alliance formation in experiential therapy for depression

“…Furthermore, since this model of therapy generally encourages client agency, future research should also investigate experiential therapists' response to client Assertion & Separation behavior. Finally, while negatively associated with the alliance during first sessions, during which establishing a strong relationship and interpersonal closeness takes priority, client assertion may have different associations with outcomes in later stages of therapy when such behavior may mark development of self-confidence and agency for some clients (Pos & Greenberg, 2012).…”

“That chair work thing was great”: a pilot study of group-based emotion-focused therapy for anxiety and depression

“…Painful or distressing maladaptive emotions are identified and experientially explored in order to access and experience adaptive emotion, transforming the problematic maladaptive emotion responses to adaptive ones (Elliott et al, 2004;Greenberg, 2008Greenberg, , 2010Greenberg & Pascual-Leone, 2006;Pascual-Leone, 2009;Pascual-Leone & Greenberg, 2007;Pos & Greenberg, 2007). EFT is marker-guided and process-directive (Elliott et al, 2004;Greenberg, 2010Greenberg, , 2011Pos & Greenberg, 2012); meaning that specific problematic emotional-processing states are identified in-session (i.e. markers) and provide an opportunity for specific intervention techniques (i.e.…”

The role of emotional intelligence in symptom reduction after psychotherapy in a heterogeneous psychiatric sample

“…In addition, specific therapies explicitly aiming at enhancing skills in the domain of emotional intelligence exist and seem to be promising in the treatment of various psychiatric disorders [33][34][35]. It would be worth examining if a more explicit focus on the enhancement of EI skills in regular cognitive behavioral therapies, but also in other forms of psychotherapy, may increase their efficacy over the longer term.…”

“…Enhancement of emotion awareness and emotion regulation skills are important facets of many forms of psychotherapy. In some therapies, these skills are explicitly focused on, such as in Emotion-Focused Therapy [33,34] or Mentalization-Based Treatment [35,36]. There is some evidence that EI skills are indeed learnable.…”