Otolaryngology boot camps: Current landscape and future directions

Abstract

Objectives Simulation‐based boot camps have gained popularity over the past few years, with some surgical specialties implementing mandatory national boot camps. However, there is no consensus in otolaryngology on boot camp timing, learner level, or curriculum. The purpose of this study is to examine the current landscape and gather opinions regarding future curriculum and standardization of boot camps in otolaryngology. Methods A survey was developed to examine current resident participation and boot camp content while also seeking opinions regarding improving boot camp enrollment and standardizing curriculum. A cross‐sectional survey of all otolaryngology residency program directors in the United States and Puerto Rico was performed via SurveyMonkey. Responses were collected anonymously, and results were analyzed by descriptive statistical analysis. Results Of the 45% (48 of 106) who responded, 76.6% reported their residents participate in boot camps. The most common skills taught were basic suturing and airway management skills. The majority (95%) was likely to send residents to a local boot camp, with 56% favoring early postgraduate year (PGY)‐1 participation and 42% favoring a 1‐day boot camp. Subsidized expenses, improved regional access, and supplementary boot camp information would help the program director in their decision to send residents to boot camp. Only 32% felt boot camps should be standardized, and 27% felt they should be mandatory. Conclusion Many otolaryngology residency programs participate in boot camps. Additional data on the benefits of boot camps, improved access, and reduced financial burden may improve participation. Further discussion of ideal timing, PGY level, and standardized curriculum should occur in conjunction with the otolaryngology academic societies and oversight from accreditation and certifying bodies. Level of Evidence NA Laryngoscope, 129:2707–2712, 2019

A Multidisciplinary Basic Airway Skills Boot Camp for Novice Trainees

“…Every topic covered in our simulation boot camp, including the ASA difficult airway algorithm, resulted in statistically significant increases in comfort levels and decreases in discomfort and unfamiliarity upon completion of the boot camp experience. These findings echo those of other similar studies that evaluated the utility of boot camp training among novice surgical trainees [ 2 , 9 - 12 ].…”

An innovative and safe way to train novice ear nose and throat residents through simulation: the SimORL experience

“…Our results are in line with that of other similar events both in the field of otorhinolaryngology as well as in other medical specialties 26,27 . Recently, Dean et al conducted a cross-sectional survey of all otolaryngology residency program directors in the United States and Puerto Rico: based on the participants' answers, the authors concluded that simulation-based boot camps can be a significant and valuable component of residency training 28 .…”

Non-technical Skills Simulation Training

“…Although non-technical skills training in Otolaryngology is a relatively new concept, there is an increasing amount of simulation activity within the literature. However, despite this, a recent cross-sectional survey by Dean et al in 2019 [11] to all Otolaryngology residency programme directors, in the USA and Porto Rico, revealed that 76% of programme directors did not think it was important to include training in nontechnical skills at training boot camps.…”