Outsourcing the State’s responsibilities? Third Sector Organizations supporting migrant families’ participation in schools in Catalonia and London

Abstract

Based on two case studies of Third Sector Organizations (TSOs) working with schools and parents in Catalonia and London, this paper aims to discuss some of the implications of 'participative' programs aimed at involving those migrant families seen by schools as 'hard to reach'. Firstly, we describe how an ambiguous notion of participation can shift responsibilities to families and leave internal school practices free from critical gaze.Secondly, we focus on the complexities and tensions involved in the process of partnering TSOs with schools, because of the bureaucratic nature of educational institutions and unresolved conflicts of interests and responsibilities. Finally, we argue that the potential of these initiatives were limited and diluted by being stand-alone and time-limited. Our analysis suggests that, in spite of their apparent success, they ended up being part of powerful authorizing narratives that justify the outsourcing of public services and the abdication of State's responsibilities.

The Third Sector in Public Governance in Nigeria: Concept, Identity and Prospects

“…A significant development in this search for answers is the renewed scholarly and practitioner interest in third sector organisations (TSOs). This sector has, in significant respects, changed the way state actors engage citizens in co-creation and co-construction activities, particularly in the industrialised world (Bourgeon 2014;Bushouse 2017;Daekin 2001;Paniagua & D"Angelo 2016;Salamon 2012;2000). The argument is that governments have exhausted their capacity to play the sole provider in society.…”

Partnership of schools and civil society organisations to support education of students of varied linguistic backgrounds—The situation in the Czech Republic, Italy and Spain

“…Partnerships or networks of various stakeholders include governments, governmental institutions, civil society, universities, schools and families (Chrispeels, 2015; Koyama & Bakuza, 2017; López‐Azuaga & Suárez Riveiro, 2018; Paniagua & D'Angelo, 2017; Rah et al, 2009). Education policy analysts and researchers have studied if and how such partnership networks may contribute to achieving desired goals.…”

Teacher Training in Linguistic Diversity within Inclusive Education: Cooperation between Non-governmental Non-profit Organizations and Educational Institutions. Situation in Three European Countries

“…They are independent actors, a voice for marginalized populations, who are in action when the state is unwilling to act; and who can relieve the burden on the state to provide education for all age groups. According to Paniagua and D'Angelo (2017) NPOs can operate also as a bridge between families and schools. This partnership may foster a long-term vision and provide more stability in the distribution of power between schools and families.…”

“…An important determinant of inclusion in schools is the co-operation of all actors shaping an inclusive environment. Frequently pronounced networks include governments, governmental institutions, civil society organizations, universities, schools and families (Chrispeels, 2015;Koyama & Bakuza, 2017;López-Azuaga & Suárez Riveiro, 2018;Paniagua & D'Angelo, 2017;Rah, Choi & Nguyen, 2009). Non-profit organizations, with their flexible policies, independent budgets, and tackling "wicked issues" (Vangen & Huxham, 2012), can offer a range of professional public services (Kendall, 2005) from which the whole education policy can benefit.…”