Stratigraphic cycles form an underlying high‐resolution chronostratigraphic structure for much of the sedimentary record. However, before their chronostratigraphic utility can be realized they must be reliably correlated. A new integrated cyclic, quantitative lithologic and faunal method of correlating meter‐scale cycles has been developed for a 12 m interval of the Miami‐town Shale in the Upper Ordovician of the Cincinnati, Ohio area. First, using lithologic criteria alone, six flooding‐surface‐bound (shale‐on‐limestone) shoaling‐upward (shale‐to‐limestone) cycles were delineated and correlated between seven outcrop sections within a 30 km radius; many correlations were ambiguous. Unusual fossil occurrences constrain correlations of cycles 3 and 4, and the limited presence of a dalmanellid, Heterorthina fairmountensis, shows that the flooding surface above cycle 3 lies 10 cm below the lithologic limestone‐shale contact. Cluster analysis of faunal abundance data constrained correlations between all cycles and showed a major transition at the top of cycle 2, again below the lithologic limestone‐shale contact. Finally, faunal depth gradient fluctuations interpreted from ordination of faunal abundance data confirmed and clarified the nature of cycle correlations; the major transition at the top of cycle 2 is a transgressive surface, and the middle part of cycle 3 includes the interval of maximum water depth. These features delineate a larger, 10‐m‐scale, cyclicity. The smaller, meter‐scale cycles, interpreted as averaging 40–100 ka in duration, demonstrate the potential of a ten‐to twenty‐fold increase in the resolution of the type Cincinnatian stratigraphic record.Ecostratigraphy, faunal cyclicity, cyclic stratigraphy, event stratigraphy epiboles, benthic paleoecology, Upper Ordovician, Maysvillian, Caradocian, Ashgillian, Cincinnati.