Palestinian and Norwegian Kindergarten Teachers' Perspectives on Psychosocial Support: A Qualitative Study

Abstract

The current qualitative case study aims to explore and map the concepts and the conditions for providing psychosocial support in kindergarten across two vastly different countries, Palestine and Norway. The global challenge of providing psychosocial support toward children is increasingly acknowledged. Although education is described as crucial for psychosocial support from the health sector, studies dealing with the educational perspective on this topic are rare. Data from 26 participants (10 from Gaza, 10 from Hebron and 6 from Norway) were collected in qualitative semi-structured interviews. Despite vastly different contexts, the analysis showed some important common features. Kindergarten teachers in both countries link psychosocial support conceptually to psychological and emotional knowledge. The teachers in both countries are concerned about the psychosocial support being performed repeatedly in everyday situations, such as establishing routines, paying extra attention, and calming children and creating everyday safe spaces. They give detailed descriptions of the quality of their long-term, yet professional relations with the child. Time and space are crucial challenges in both countries, and they call for more knowledge on mental health. A main difference between the two countries was the role of the community and relation to parents. The Palestinian teachers defined psychosocial support as a “set of community services,” the teachers were frustrated with the lack of parental collaboration. The Norwegian teachers downscaled or overlooked the importance of community or parents and community. The findings give overall presentations of the concepts and the conditions for providing psychosocial support in education Palestine and Norway. We argue that education not only represents sites for conducting health-directed interventions but represents important resources for developing the field of psychosocial support in collaboration with community services. Education – and especially kindergarten provides other values, knowledge, and structural resources for the development programs and knowledge on psychosocial support.

The call for an “educational footprint” in conceptualizing mental health and psychosocial support: the case of Norwegian kindergarten teachers

“…The prior study (El-Khodary et al, 2021) provided brief comparisons across two distinct national contexts, while this present study represents new analyses, research questions and units of analysis, calling for in-depth national studies of the data material.…”

“…The two studies shared certain features early in the research process, serving as a mutually informative reference group during various research phases. The prior study ( El-Khodary et al, 2021 ) provided brief comparisons across two distinct national contexts, while this present study represents new analyses, research questions and units of analysis, calling for in-depth national studies of the data material.…”

“…This paper offers a new and in-depth analysis of the Norwegian segment of data, being part of a previous comparative study on kindergarten teachers’ perspectives on psychosocial support in Palestine and Norway ( El-Khodary et al, 2021 ). The two studies shared certain features early in the research process, serving as a mutually informative reference group during various research phases.…”

“…The comparison showed that although X kindergarten teachers were more well-acquainted with the MHPSS terminology, the two countries shared many common challenges in providing psychosocial support in kindergarten. The study describe a need for further national studies to develop a more distinct “educational footprint” in the field of MHPSS ( El-Khodary et al, 2021 ). The aim of this present paper is to bring in-depth insights into teachers’ professional logic and conceptualization of psychosocial support, calling for an “educational footprint” in interprofessional work in MHPSS interventions.…”

The role and involvement of NGOs in activities related to humanitarian issues in Palestine

“…In addition, Aman Palestine is a humanitarian NGO that allocates religious, financial, and humane assistance to the Palestinian people in a completely healthy manner. Since its establishment, Aman Palestine has been successful in channeling assistance in the form of various types of projects to the Palestinian people in Palestine (El-Khodary et al, 2021).…”