Parental environmental effects due to contrasting watering adapt competitive ability, but not drought tolerance, in offspring of a semi‐arid annual Brassicaceae

Abstract

Summary1. Parental effects (PE) can be adaptive and improve offspring performance when parents and offspring experience similar environmental conditions. However, it is unknown whether adaptive PE exist also in habitats where such similarity is unlikely due to strong temporal variation. In particular, we do not know whether PE can adapt offspring to fluctuating levels of neighbour competition in such habitats.2. Here, we tested for adaptive PE in terms of two key environmental factors in a semi-arid annual system, competition and drought. While rainfall was stochastic in the study site, the competitive environment was partly predictable: higher plant densities followed after favourable (rainy) years due to high seed production. We therefore expected PE to adapt the offspring's competitive ability to these (predictable) fluctuations in plant densities, rather than to adapt the offspring's drought tolerance to the (unpredictable) occurrence of intensified drought. 3. Parental plants of Biscutella didyma, an annual Brassicaceae, were raised under favourable watering and under drought conditions. Offspring performance was then tested under a full-factorial combination of two neighbour regimes and six watering levels in the glasshouse. 4. Offspring of parents grown under favourable conditions were stronger competitors. This was associated with a small shift in phenology but not with higher parental seed provisioning. Offspring from parents grown under drought showed no improved drought tolerance. Moreover, no PE were detectable when offspring were grown without neighbours. 5. Our results suggest a novel path of adaptive PE: higher competitive ability was induced in offspring that were more likely to experience high neighbour densities. Together with the lack of adaptive PE towards drought tolerance, this emphasizes that a correlation between parental and offspring environment is crucial for adaptive PE to evolve. Our results also call for the inclusion of competitive effects in future PE studies. 6. Synthesis. This study demonstrates the important role of adaptive PE for plant fitness (regarding competition) but also their limits (regarding drought) in temporally variable environments, based on the predictability of the respective environmental factor.

Clinal population divergence in an adaptive parental environmental effect that adjusts seed banking

“…This distinction may seem small, but it has important implications. Even though precipitation can vary unpredictably across years, it can still cause a correlated effect on neighbour density in the offspring environment (Metz et al, 2015). Therefore, populations of annual plants that persist under these environmental conditions are expected to exhibit a parental environmental effect on between-year seed dormancy.…”

Spatial and temporal aridity gradients provide poor proxies for plant–plant interactions under climate change: a large‐scale experiment

“…An 'easy' alternative may be to study responses to in situ temporal between-year variation in climatic conditions. While avoiding confounding effects in a similar way as experiments, the drawback of such temporal approaches may only be that erratic annual climatic variation differs from a consistent and directional change imposed by permanent experimental manipulations, namely temporal changes are inherent in ecosystems and thus selected for specific adaptations that in turn could veil responses to directional changes, such as buffering effects of seed dormancy (Tielb€ orger & Valleriani 2005; Lampei & Tielb€ orger 2010), large seed size (Metz et al 2010) or adaptive parental effects (Metz, von Oppen & Tielb€ orger 2015). Interestingly though, between-year variations in plant-plant interactions have repeatedly contradicted spatial trends even when performed in very similar study systems (e.g.…”

Scale-dependent natural variation in larval nutritional reserves in a marine invertebrate: implications for recruitment and cross-ecosystem coupling

“…as in coral reef fish; Hamilton et al 2008). Evolutionary theory predicts that adaptive phenotypic responses should arise when the new environment is predictable (Marshall et al 2010, Metz et al 2015 and the gradient in chlorophyll found in West Scotland is predictable over several generations (Fig. S3).…”