The human -globin locus is activated transcriptionally by a complex series of events that culminate in appropriate temporal and tissue-specific control over five separate genes during embryonic and early postnatal development. One cis-regulatory element in the locus, originally identified as an enhancer 3 to the A␥-globin gene, more recently has been suggested to harbor alternative or additional properties, including stage-specific silencer, insulator, nuclear matrix, or chromosome scaffold attachment activities. We have re-evaluated the activity during erythropoiesis that is conferred by this element by deleting it from a yeast artificial chromosome (YAC) containing the entire human -globin locus and then assaying for the expression of each gene at each developmental stage after incorporation of the mutant YAC into the mouse germline. The data show that loss of the A␥-globin 3 element confers no phenotype in six independent lines of intact YAC mutant transgenic mice, thus demonstrating (minimally) that any activities attributable to this element are fully compensated by other DNA sequences within the -globin locus.At least 17 discrete transcriptional control elements lie within the human -globin gene locus. These include the five DNaseI hypersensitive sites lying from 6 to 24 kbp 5Ј to the -globin gene [the locus control region (LCR) (1-3)], the promoters of each of five separate genes, and distinct modulatory elements that lie either within, or in relatively close proximity to, one or another of the genes.Among these gene-proximal regulatory elements, one of the earliest to be identified was an enhancer element discovered over a decade ago in transient transfection experiments (4). This sequence lies 410 bp 3Ј to the A␥-globin gene and is confined within boundaries originally described by a 757-bp EcoRI͞HindIII fragment. With passing time, however, the bona fide regulatory activity conferred by this element became more controversial because subsequent studies in transgenic mice implicated this same element in the stage-specific and autonomous silencing of the A␥-globin gene in adult stage erythroid cells (5, 6). Subsequently, in vitro studies implicated the same element as a chromatin structural motif that could participate in tethering the locus to chromosome scaffolds or to the nuclear matrix (7). More recently, it was shown that this sequence, in collaboration with the LCR, is able to shelter ␥-globin transgenes from variegation effects caused by the neighboring chromatin into which they randomly integrate, suggesting that this combination of cis-elements can provide insulation from the repressive effects of surrounding heterochromatin (8). However, even the most current analyses demonstrate that the activity due to this sequence is still controversial and unresolved (9). These multiple observations and seemingly disparate conclusions then provoke several questions: Is this A␥-globin 3Ј element (referred to hereafter as the A␥3ЈE) an enhancer, a silencer, or a sequence required for appropriate c...