Partitioning and mapping uncertainties in ensembles of forecasts of species turnover under climate change

Abstract

Forecasts of species range shifts under climate change are fraught with uncertainties and ensemble forecasting may provide a framework to deal with such uncertainties. Here, a novel approach to partition the variance among modeled attributes, such as richness or turnover, and map sources of uncertainty in ensembles of forecasts is presented. We model the distributions of 3837 New World birds and project them into 2080. We then quantify and map the relative contribution of different sources of uncertainty from alternative methods for niche modeling, general circulation models (AOGCM), and emission scenarios. The greatest source of uncertainty in forecasts of species range shifts arises from using alternative methods for niche modeling, followed by AOGCM, and their interaction. Our results concur with previous studies that discovered that projections from alternative models can be extremely varied, but we provide a new analytical framework to examine uncertainties in models by quantifying their importance and mapping their patterns.

The impact of climate change on the geographical distribution of two vectors of Chagas disease: implications for the force of infection

“…Although this is not the usual approach to model species distributions since it may overestimate the geographical distribution of a species introducing a great number of false positives, the presence points derived from geographical distribution atlas allow us to understand large-scale distribution patterns of species [94,95]. Nevertheless, the use of data based upon individual occurrences from surveys would not necessarily produce more accurate suitability predictions, because this kind of data may itself introduce uncertainties related to different sampling efforts, both in space and time, introducing cases of false negatives.…”

A large historical refugium explains spatial patterns of genetic diversity in a Neotropical savanna tree species

“…The selected models were geographically classified for presence and absence of species by using the threshold that maximizes specificity plus sensibility, and then the consensus maps were computed from the frequency of initial models supporting the occurrence of the species in each cell of the grid. The consensual frequency is then interpreted and used in further analyses as a measure of environmental suitability [see details of the ensemble approach in Diniz-Filho et al (2009) and Collevatti et al (2012a)]. The combinations of all modelling components (12 algorithms Â5 AOGCMs) resulted in 60 consensual predictive maps for each time period.…”

Potenciais efeitos das mudanças climáticas futuras sobre a distribuiçãode um anuro da Caatinga Rhinella granulosa (Anura, Bufonidae)

“…Para a construção dos modelos correlativos aplicamos o método de Distância Euclidiana, utilizando o software BIOENSEMBLES (veja Diniz-Filho et al, 2009;Rangel et al, 2009), o qual consiste em medir a similaridade de cada ponto de ocorrência em relação à média (ou ao centro) do espaço ecológico, gerando, assim, um envelope circular. Desta forma, os valores mais altos apresentados no mapa referem-se a locais mais distantes do nicho ótimo da espécie, ao passo que valores mais baixos representam locais mais adequados à sobrevivência da espécie e semelhantes ao nicho ótimo.…”