Patient Similarity in Prediction Models Based on Health Data: A Scoping Review

Abstract

BackgroundPhysicians and health policy makers are required to make predictions during their decision making in various medical problems. Many advances have been made in predictive modeling toward outcome prediction, but these innovations target an average patient and are insufficiently adjustable for individual patients. One developing idea in this field is individualized predictive analytics based on patient similarity. The goal of this approach is to identify patients who are similar to an index patient and derive insights from the records of similar patients to provide personalized predictions..ObjectiveThe aim is to summarize and review published studies describing computer-based approaches for predicting patients’ future health status based on health data and patient similarity, identify gaps, and provide a starting point for related future research.MethodsThe method involved (1) conducting the review by performing automated searches in Scopus, PubMed, and ISI Web of Science, selecting relevant studies by first screening titles and abstracts then analyzing full-texts, and (2) documenting by extracting publication details and information on context, predictors, missing data, modeling algorithm, outcome, and evaluation methods into a matrix table, synthesizing data, and reporting results.ResultsAfter duplicate removal, 1339 articles were screened in abstracts and titles and 67 were selected for full-text review. In total, 22 articles met the inclusion criteria. Within included articles, hospitals were the main source of data (n=10). Cardiovascular disease (n=7) and diabetes (n=4) were the dominant patient diseases. Most studies (n=18) used neighborhood-based approaches in devising prediction models. Two studies showed that patient similarity-based modeling outperformed population-based predictive methods.ConclusionsInterest in patient similarity-based predictive modeling for diagnosis and prognosis has been growing. In addition to raw/coded health data, wavelet transform and term frequency-inverse document frequency methods were employed to extract predictors. Selecting predictors with potential to highlight special cases and defining new patient similarity metrics were among the gaps identified in the existing literature that provide starting points for future work. Patient status prediction models based on patient similarity and health data offer exciting potential for personalizing and ultimately improving health care, leading to better patient outcomes.

Computerized Childbirth Monitoring Tools for Health Care Providers Managing Labor: A Scoping Review

“…This is a drawback, but the main sources are wide enough for an adequate sample and similar reviewers [17,20,40] increasingly adopt this approach. We also started the search with broad terms and narrowed them down as we saved different papers for subsequent analyses.…”

Cohort-based T-SSIM Visual Computing for Radiation Therapy Prediction and Exploration

“…To predict a patient's dose distribution, we use a weighted k-nearestneighbors algorithm, which is a common method of prediction in similarity-based health models [39]. The dose distribution prediction was calculated as the per-organ dose average of the k most similar patients:…”

Predicting treatment repetitions in the implant denture therapy process

“…However, unfortunately, there is no silver bullet. Hence, we analzyed related work to identify classification algorithms that have been applied in similar healtchare contexts [13], [14]. As a result, we selected three promising candidates: (1) decision trees (DTs), (2) random forests (RFs), and (3) and Support Vector Machines (SVMs).…”