Patients’ descriptions of the relation between physical symptoms and negative emotions: a qualitative analysis of primary care consultations

Abstract

BackgroundPrimary care guidelines for the management of persistent, often ‘medically unexplained’, physical symptoms encourage GPs to discuss with patients how these symptoms relate to negative emotions. However, many GPs experience difficulties in reaching a shared understanding with patients.AimTo explore how patients with persistent symptoms describe their negative emotions in relation to their physical symptoms in primary care consultations, in order to help GPs recognise the patient’s starting points in such discussions.Design and settingA qualitative analysis of 47 audiorecorded extended primary care consultations with 15 patients with persistent physical symptoms.MethodThe types of relationships patients described between their physical symptoms and their negative emotions were categorised using content analysis. In a secondary analysis, the study explored whether patients made transitions between the types of relations they described through the course of the consultations.ResultsAll patients talked spontaneously about their negative emotions. Three main categories of relations between these emotions and physical symptoms were identified: separated (negation of a link between the two); connected (symptom and emotion are distinct entities that are connected); and inseparable (symptom and emotion are combined within a single entity). Some patients showed a transition between categories of relations during the intervention.ConclusionPatients describe different types of relations between physical symptoms and negative emotions in consultations. Physical symptoms can be attributed to emotions when patients introduce this link themselves, but this link tends to be denied when introduced by the GP. Awareness of the ways patients discuss these relations could help GPs to better understand the patient’s view and, in this way, collaboratively move towards constructive explanations and symptom management strategies.

Measures of emotion regulation: Convergence and psychometric properties of the difficulties in emotion regulation scale and emotion regulation questionnaire

“…Assessing emotion understanding and regulation could be a valuable first screen of psychiatric symptoms. Studies in primary care settings have also indicated an association between negative emotions (e.g., low mood, guilt, frustration) and physical health (Bekhuis et al, 2020).…”

Patients’ experiences with fluctuations in persistent physical symptoms: a qualitative study

“…However, when the GP introduced this link it tended to be denied. 30 This again underlines the stigma that still pertains on mental distress and its relation to physical health.…”

Body Reprogramming: Reframing the Fibromyalgia narrative and providing an integrative therapeutic model

“…These latter explanations typically put forward the psycho-analytic notion that mental distress has evolved into body symptoms. In addition to being scientifically untestable, this approach has resulted in fractious clinical consultations and often hostile rejection by patients and support groups ( Bekhuis et al, 2020 ; Rief and Broadbent, 2007 ).…”