Perceived ambiguity as a barrier to intentions to learn genome sequencing results

Abstract

Many variants that could be returned from genome sequencing may be perceived as ambiguous—lacking reliability, credibility, or adequacy. Little is known about how perceived ambiguity influences thoughts about sequencing results. Participants (n=494) in an NIH genome sequencing study completed a baseline survey before sequencing results were available. We examined how perceived ambiguity regarding sequencing results and individual differences in medical ambiguity aversion and tolerance for uncertainty were associated with cognitions and intentions concerning sequencing results. Perceiving sequencing results as more ambiguous was associated with less favorable cognitions about results and lower intentions to learn and share results. Among participants low in tolerance for uncertainty or optimism, greater perceived ambiguity was associated with lower intentions to learn results for non-medically actionable diseases; medical ambiguity aversion did not moderate any associations. Results are consistent with the phenomenon of “ambiguity aversion” and may influence whether people learn and communicate genomic information.

Optimism and Spontaneous Self-affirmation are Associated with Lower Likelihood of Cognitive Impairment and Greater Positive Affect among Cancer Survivors

“…In the present study, individuals higher in optimism consistently reported better health on nearly all indices examined (with the exception of information seeking), even when controlling for SSA and sociodemographic factors. These results are consistent with prior research demonstrating benefits of optimism, including more active coping strategies (18, 19, 21), the ability to make prudent decisions about where to allocate one’s energies (57), and a reduction of the negative association of greater perceived ambiguity with lower intentions to learn potentially useful health information (58). Of course, optimism could have shown such a consistent association with outcomes because all outcomes were self-reported, and optimistic people may be more likely to evaluate these factors positively.…”

How Patients View Lung Cancer Screening. The Role of Uncertainty in Medical Decision Making

“…Individual characteristics that impact patient decision making about cancer screening and other medical interventions include one's tolerance of uncertainty or ambiguity (20)(21)(22). These constructs are closely related but have been distinguished in one analysis by a focus on current (ambiguity) and future health states (uncertainty) (23).…”

The role of current affect, anticipated affect and spontaneous self-affirmation in decisions to receive self-threatening genetic risk information

“…These items also appear as outcomes in separate papers examining the role of individual differences in information avoidance on intentions to receive sequencing results (Taber et al, in press-a) optimism and risk perceptions on intentions to receive sequencing results (Taber et al, 2014), and ambiguity-related constructs and optimism on intentions to receive and share sequencing results (Taber et al, in press-b). Ancillary analyses including predictors from other manuscripts as covariates did not change the pattern of results.…”