Perceptions of and about women as managers: investigating job involvement, self‐esteem and attitudes

Abstract

PurposeTo investigate specific barriers that might be hindering Maltese women from achieving a managerial position.Design/methodology/approachThis study is based on research by Cromie. Barriers are classified into two main categories; internal and external barriers. Job‐involvement and work‐based self‐esteem are considered to be internal barriers, whereas attitudes towards women in management are considered to be external barriers. The total population was 200, consisting of male and female middle managers, female and male employees and B. Commerce students.FindingsResults indicate no differences between job involvement and work‐based self‐esteem of male and female managers. On the other hand, both male employees and students seem to hold more stereotypical attitudes towards women in management than their female counterparts.Research limitations/implicationsOne of the basic limitations of this study was the sample size since small samples make it difficult to generalize. Further research may focus on two main areas. First, it would be useful to have qualitative research on the work experiences of female managers to further investigate the various factors that have helped and hindered women thorough their career advancement. Secondly, research on corporate climate can be helpful in identifying organizational practices that might be blocking female career prospects. Finally, a study considering how attitudes can be reshaped through the educational system and through the use of the media can also help to reduce gender stereotypes.Practical implicationsThis study indicates that women often have to face several attitudinal barriers, which in turn may explain the lack of female participation in managerial occupations. A change in organizational policies can help women to overcome these barriers.Originality/valueThis paper confirms that, as in several countries, Maltese women are facing several barriers, which are hindering their career prospects. It also highlights the important role of organizations in reducing workplace barriers.

Relationships among self‐esteem, job adjustment and service attitude amongst male nurses: a structural equation model

“…They indicated that health staff members with low selfesteem also have negative service attitude and low job productivity. Moreover, a significant positive correlation was shown to exist between self-esteem and job involvement (Brown 1996, Cortis & Cassar 2005 and between self-esteem and organisational commitment (Pierce et al 1989). The study by Naderi et al (2009) indicated a significant difference between gender and self-esteem.…”

Career attitudes and subjective career success: tackling gender differences

“…In addition, women managers may need to find their own career paths due the scarcity of women in top leadership, and thus, to the lack of role models as they could not break the glass ceiling. Tlaiss and Kauser (2010) observe that a number of studies have identified organizational barriers that prevent women from advancing such as constraining societal and cultural practices (Benson and Yukongdi, 2006;Wilson, 2003), discriminatory gender-specific factors (Parker and Fagenson, 1994;Powell, 2000), the anti-female nature of organizations (Cortis and Cassar, 2005;Eagly and Carli, 2007;Weir, 2003), and institutional discrimination such as limited access to networking processes, lack of mentoring, and limited training and development opportunities (Cordano et al, 2002;Lahtinen and Wilson, 1994).…”

Barriers to Career Progression: A Study of the Perceptions of Nepali Women Employees

“…Researchers have categorized the barriers as internal and external (Cortis & Cassar, 2005), or as glass ceiling and glass wall (Powell & Graves, 2003), or as individual, organizational, and societal (Moorosi, 2010).…”