Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM-IM) is a multicarrier transmission technology that modulates information bits not just onto subcarriers by means of M-ary constellation mapping but also onto selected (active) subcarrier indices. Consequently, errors can occur in OFDM-IM systems indices in addition to the errors of M-ary symbols. This paper analyzes the error scenarios and derives mathematical expressions for the error performance based on the maximum likelihood (ML) detection. In evaluating the bit error rate (BER) in the additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN) channel, some assumptions are made and our analytical result show that the BER of OFDM-IM system is a weighted sum of exponential functions and Q-functions. Our general BER expression has been shown to be in excellent agreement with numerical simulation and proven to be accurate and can serve as a reference for the design and evaluation of any arbitrary size and configuration of OFDM-IM systems.