The retentive principle of hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) with a water (W)−acetonitrile (ACN) mobile phase (MP) and a hydrophilic stationary phase is the formation of a W-rich layer with a rigid and diffuse part in the immediate and extended surface region, respectively. Through molecular dynamics simulations of the adsorption of W−acetone (Ace), W−methanol (MeOH), and MeOH−ACN mixtures to a hydrophilic silica surface, we evaluate their MP potential for aqueous and nonaqueous HILIC. We analyze solvent and hydrogen-bond density profiles, solvent−surface coordination, as well as local solvent orientation, mobility, and composition. Our data show that W−Ace mixtures closely mimic the behavior of W− ACN mixtures, whereas W−MeOH mixtures fail as HILIC MP because the similar affinity of the silica surface for W and MeOH prevents preferential adsorption of W. MeOH−ACN mixtures form a rigid MeOH layer that reverses the surface polarity and prohibits formation of a diffuse MeOH layer in the extended surface region. Generally, a rigid layer at a hydrophilic surface is formed by binary mixtures whose solvents have sufficiently different hydrogen-bonding abilities, and a diffuse layer is formed when the rigid layer maintains hydrophilic properties.