“…Likewise, the magnitudes of the observed electric signals at the surface are high (with fields of about 2 x 10 -5 V m -1 ), and events at earthquake-focus depth might need to produce immense signals (10 5 A • m or more) to match observation (Honkura and Kuwata, 1993). Thus mechanisms that occur close to the surface are to be favored (Johnston, 1997;Park et al, 1993;Park, 1996), for example, fluctuations in groudnwater (Varotsos et al, 2019). Critical work was organized in 1993 (Tectonophysics,Volume 224) and 1996 (Lighthill, 1996), and highlights seven features of this VAN method that are problematic:…”