This paper summarizes a project seminar
in analytical chemistry
that includes a method comparison approach and collaborative learning.
In this project seminar, 12 students worked in four groups, each of
which focused on one method for quantitative element analysis, including
flame atomic absorption spectroscopy, inductively coupled plasma mass
spectrometry, inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectroscopy,
and X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy. The seminar was structured into
two phases. In the first phase, students became familiar with their
method and instrumentation through characterizing the method’s
capabilities for the analysis of a steel reference sample and then
sharing and comparing results between groups. In the second phase,
all groups used insights gained during the first phase to design and
perform experiments with their methods to solve an analytical challenge.
Specifically, the aim of each group was to quantify major, minor,
and trace element concentrations from periglacial sediment layers
from the hills southeast of Zürich, Switzerland. At the end
of phase two, the student-groups presented and compared their results
in a joint public poster presentation. Assessment was based on material
produced by the participants: posters, teaching materials, method
profiles, and written reports. The course evaluation indicates a high
satisfaction with the course. The student-centered approach enabled
students to get extensive hands-on experience in order to acquire
subject-specific skills as well as soft skills. It is well-suited
for upper-level undergraduate and graduate students for specialization
in analytical chemistry. Further insights, observations, potential
for improvement, and limitations are discussed.