BACKGROUNDEfficient utilization of phosphorus (P) has been a major challenge for sustainable agriculture. However, the responses of fertilizer rate, region, soil properties, cropping systems and genotypes to P have not been investigated comprehensively and systematically.RESULTSA comprehensive analysis of 9863 fertilizer‐P experiments on rice cultivation in China showed that rice yield increased first and then fell down with the addition of P fertilizer, and the highest yield of 7963 kg ha−1 was observed under 100% P treatment. Under 100% P treatment, the yield response of applied P (YRP) and agronomic efficiency of applied P (AEP) were 12.8% and 30.1 kg ha−1, respectively. Lower soil pH (< 5.5) and organic matter (< 30.0 g kg−1) were associated with lower YRP and AEP. By contrast, soil available P < 25.0 mg kg−1 resulted in decreased YRP (15.3 to 11.4%) and AEP (32.3 kg kg−1 to 26.2 kg kg−1), whereas soil available P > 25.0 mg kg−1 maintained the relatively stable YRP and AEP. Also, the YRP and AEP were significantly higher for single‐cropping rice compared to other cropping systems. Moreover, the rice genotypes such as ‘Longdun’, ‘Kendao’ and ‘Jigeng’ had higher YRP and AEP than the average value. Overall, the fertilizer‐P rate was the primary factor affecting YRP and AEP, and the recommended P fertilizer rate can be reduced by 9–21 kg P ha−1 compared to existing expert recommendations.CONCLUSIONThe present study highlights the role of fertilizer‐P rate in maximizing the YRP and AEP, thereby providing a strong basis for future fertilizer management in rice cultivation systems. © 2023 Society of Chemical Industry.