The photoelectrochemical properties of p-type gallium phosphide (GaP) (111)A electrodes before and after a two-step chlorination/Grignard reaction sequence have been assessed. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy indicated both a change in the flat-band potential in water and decreased sensitivity of the band edge energetics toward pH for GaP(111)A surfaces following modification. Separate stability tests were performed to gauge the susceptibilities of unmodified and CH 3 -terminated p-GaP(111)A photoelectrodes toward reductive degradation under illumination. The steady-state photoelectrochemical results showed modification of GaP(111)A with −CH 3 groups significantly enhanced p-GaP stability. Separately, sub-bandgap photocurrent measurements were collected to assess relative changes in surface states acting as recombination centers. In the absence of any dye, the sub-bandgap photocurrent from trapping/detrapping of charge carriers in surface states was higher for unmodified p-GaP photoelectrodes than for CH 3 -terminated p-GaP(111)A. Further, sensitized photocurrents of p-GaP photoelectrodes with Brilliant Green were systematically higher after modification with −CH 3 groups, indicating a deactivation of a surface recombination pathway after surface modification. Collectively, this work illustrates a rational chemical strategy to modify and augment the pertinent interfacial properties of p-GaP photocathodes in an aqueous photoelectrochemical system.