Physician versus Paramedic in the Setting of Ground Forces Operations: Are They Interchangeable?

Abstract

Background: The setting of military ground force operations can be demanding and requires a matched medical assistance plan. A major consideration is the type of medical caregiver that is assigned to the mission. We studied the similarities, differences, advantages, and disadvantages of physicians versus paramedics in this scenario. Methods: We interviewed 20 ground force physicians, highly experienced in this setting. We summarized their responses and formulated quantitative decision-making tables regarding two sorts of missions: a long-duration mission, far from friendly definitive care, and a short-duration mission, close to friendly hospitals. Results: The major areas in which physicians and paramedics differ, pertinent to a ground force operation are: formal education, on-job training, knowledge base, ability to treat a wide variety of medical conditions, ability to perform manual lifesaving procedures, social and moral impact, availability, physical fitness, combat skills, and cost. Of a maximum score of 100 points, for a long-term mission a physician scores 77.7 points while a paramedic scores 63.6 points. The scores for a shortterm mission are 72.7 and 67.9, respectively. Discussion: Physicians and paramedics are distinct groups of medical caregivers and this is also true for the setting of ground force operations. They are not interchangeable. Our data show that a physician has a relative advantage over a paramedic, especially in long-term missions, far from friendly facilities. Conclusion: A physician is the first choice for all kinds of military ground force missions while a paramedic can be a reasonable substitute for missions of short duration, close to definitive care.

Exploring the characteristics of successful prehospital trauma care teams: Insights from military trauma care simulations

“…It is possible that in our cohort, paramedics have more prehospital clinical experience than physicians due to their civilian training in ambulance services. Levy et al 29 demonstrated these technical skill differences when they examined whether military physicians and paramedics are interchangeable in military operations. While these disparities may explain the differences we have observed in technical skill assessments, a systematic review by Dyson et al 30 did not find clear evidence for an association between ALS provider experience and technical ALS skill outcomes.…”

The experience of a battalion physician in the Yom Kippur War

“…It is especially important during periods of intense stress 5. Although I conducted a daily sick call, I also decided that whenever possible I would visit the four companies in our battalion every morning,1 thinking that by visiting on a daily basis I would be more available to the soldiers.…”

Unfit for Duty? Evaluation of 4 Years of Paramedic Preemployment Fitness Screening Test Results

“…[1][2][3][4] The core function of an ambulance service is to provide prehospital emergency medical care and transportation to hospital for the acutely sick and injured. 5,6 In the execution of these duties, paramedics may be required to perform physically demanding tasks or be exposed to occupational hazards, which can potentially lead to morbidity or mortality. [7][8][9][10] Research has indicated that there are relatively high levels of occupational injury and illness associated with the paramedic profession.…”