Physician Workflow in Two Distinctive Emergency Departments: An Observational Study

Abstract

Objectives We characterize physician workflow in two distinctive emergency departments (ED). Physician practices mediated by electronic health records (EHR) are explored within the context of organizational complexity for the delivery of care. Methods Two urban clinical sites, including an academic teaching ED, were selected. Fourteen physicians were recruited. Overall, 62 hours of direct clinical observations were conducted characterizing clinical activities (EHR use, team communication, and patient care). Data were analyzed using qualitative open-coding techniques and descriptive statistics. Timeline belts were used to represent temporal events. Results At site 1, physicians, engaged in more team communication, followed by direct patient care. Although physicians spent 61% of their clinical time at workstations, only 25% was spent on the EHR, primarily for clinical documentation and review. Site 2 physicians engaged primarily in direct patient care spending 52% of their time at a workstation, and 31% dedicated to EHRs, focused on chart review. At site 1, physicians showed nonlinear complex workflow patterns with a greater frequency of multitasking and interruptions, resulting in workflow fragmentation. In comparison, at site 2, a less complex environment with a unique patient assignment system, resulting in a more linear workflow pattern. Conclusion The nature of the clinical practice and EHR-mediated workflow reflects the ED work practices. Physicians in more complex organizations may be less efficient because of the fragmented workflow. However, these effects can be mitigated by effort distribution through team communication, which affords inherent safety checks.

Interaction Time with Electronic Health Records: A Systematic Review

“…17 Interaction time with the EHR is not a sufficient measure for workflow assessment as disruptions to clinical workflow associated with EHR are not captured. 68 The average daily total logged time spent on "desktop medicine" was more than 50% of the physician day. 69 Apart from common EHR tasks such as authoring and viewing notes, desktop medicine includes other activities such as communicating with patients through patient portals, communicating with colleagues, searching for the literature, billing, and other clerical activities.…”

Understanding the Digital Disruption of Health Care: An Ethnographic Study of Real-Time Multidisciplinary Clinical Behavior in a New Digital Hospital

“…Ethnography (observational recording of specific populations, groups, or communities) can provide a rich understanding of the real-time disruption and complexity of digital hospital transformation and its impact on clinical behavior. 14 15 16 17 18 Understanding can then mature from “work as imagined” to “work as done” – what actually happens in real-time. 15 To our knowledge, ethnography is yet to be applied to large-scale digital disruption of health care and can be used to guide clinicians, decision-makers, and health services to optimize future digital hospital transformations.…”

Novice Doctors in the Emergency Department: A Scoping Review

“…Posters or pocketbooks with information on common problems (e.g., antibiotic therapy) and automated pop-ups in electronic medical records alerting the doctors of the possibility of sepsis are other examples. In addition, a lean organization of the ED with quiet working stations, linear processes, and good team communication reduces multitasking, improves efficiency, and is less complex [ 52 ].…”