We have used the pH variation in the kinetic parameters with respect to malate of NADP-malic enzyme purified from the C4 species, Flaveria trinervia, to compare the pK values of its functional groups with those for the pigeon liver NADP-malic enzyme (Ml Schimerlik, WW Cleland [1977] Biochemistry 16: 576-583) and the plant NAD-malic enzyme (KO Willeford, RT Wedding ] Plant Physiol 84: 1084-1087. Like the other enzymes, the C4 enzyme has a group with a pK of about 6.0 (6.6 for the C4 enzyme), as indicated from plots of the log V,mx/Km (Vmax = maximum rate of catalysis) versus pH, which must lose a proton for malate binding and subsequent catalysis. The optimum ionization for the C4 enzyme-NADP-Mg2+ complex occurs at pH 7.1 to 7.5. From pH 7.5 to 8.4, the Km increases, but V,,., remains constant. The log VmaxIKm plot in this pH range indicates a group with a pK of about 7.7. The other malic enzymes exhibit a similar pK. Above pH 8.4, deprotonation leads to a marked increase in Km and a decrease in V,,, for the C4 enzyme. As in the case of the animal enzyme, the log Vm,x/Km plot for the C4 enzyme appears to approach a slope of two. The curve suggests an average pK of 8.4 for the groups involved, while the animal enzyme exhibits an average pK of 9.0. The NAD-malic enzyme does not exhibit any pK values at these high pK values. We hypothesize that the putative groups with the high pK values may be at least partially responsible for the ability of the C4 NADP-malic enzyme to maintain high activity at pH 8.0 in illuminated chloroplasts.Vma. up to pH 8.0 (7, 10), while the C3 plant enzyme appears to have an optimum activity around pH 6.4 to 7.3 (4, 14). The plant NAD-ME, located in mitochondria, is similar to the C3 NADP-ME with respect to the pH at which it exhibits maximum activity (15). Of course, several factors determine the optimum pH to use for in vitro assays, but a superficial look at all MEs suggests that the C4 enzyme is a special form that has evolved for decarboxylation at high rates in illuminated choroplasts during C4 photosynthesis.Extensive mechanistic information is available for the pigeon liver NADP-ME (7, 10) and is becoming available for plant NAD-ME (15), but such information for the forms of plant NADP-ME is minimal. In light of the differences in the pH optima for the various MEs, we have used the effect of pH on the kinetic parameters with respect to malate for the F. trinervia enzyme as a means of comparing the pK values of functional groups of this putative special form of ME with those published for the pigeon liver enzyme and the plant NAD-ME.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Plant MaterialPlants of Flaveria trinervia (Spreng.) C. Mohr were grown in a greenhouse under a 14 h photoperiod during the summer months. The seed was collected locally, and the plants were fertilized with a Hoagland solution three times a week.