Plant volatiles and priority effects interactively determined initial community assembly of arthropods on multiple willow species

Abstract

Plant traits, which are often species specific, can serve as environmental filtering for community assembly on plants. At the same time, the species identity of the initially colonizing arthropods would vary between plant individuals, which would subsequently influence colonizing arthropods and community development in the later stages. However, it remains unclear whether interindividual divergence due to priority effects is equally important as plant trait-specific environmental filtering in the initial stages. In this study, we propose that plant volatile organic compounds (PVOCs) may play a crucial role as an environmental filter in the initial stages of community assembly, which can prevent the community assembly process from being purely stochastic. To test this hypothesis, we conducted short term but highly frequent monitoring (19 observations over 9 days) of arthropod community assembly on intact individuals of six willow species in a common garden. PVOC compositions were analyzed before starting the experiment and compared with arthropod compositions occurring on Days 1-2 of the experiment (earliest colonizer community) and those occurring on Days 8-9 of the experiment (subsequent colonizer community). Unintentionally, deer herbivory also occurred at night of Day 2. Distance-based statistics demonstrated that PVOC compositions were plant species specific, but neither the earliest colonizer nor the subsequent colonizer community composition could be explained by plant species identity. Rather, Procrustes analysis showed that both the PVOC composition and that of the earliest colonizer community can be used to explain the subsequent colonizer community. In addition, the linkage between PVOCs and the subsequent colonizer community was stronger on individuals with deer herbivory. These findings indicate that PVOCs have widespread effects on initial community assembly, as well as priority effects brought on by stochastic immigration, and that plant species identity only has weak and indirect effects on the actual composition of the community.

Quantifying direct and indirect effects of early‐season herbivory on reproduction across four brassicaceous plant species

“…In addition to shifts in the identity of attackers, induced plant responses that occur early in the season can affect the trajectory of insect population growth that persists throughout the development of the plant (Karban, 1993; Wold & Marquis, 1997). Although direct interactions with specific herbivore individuals are often highly transient, priority effects caused by individual attackers may thus influence the subsequent interactions plants are exposed to, even after the causal biotic interaction ceases to persist (Han et al., 2020; Wurst et al., 2015; Yoneya et al., 2023).…”