Political Culture and the Study of Chinese Politics

Abstract

It is both a truth and a truism that Chinese politics cannot be understood without reference to Chinese culture (a truth and truism that would apply to any other society as well). But within the academic discipline of political science political culture has lost status over the past generation as not conducive to the development of empirical political theory. The usual candidate for replacement is rational choice theory. But properly understood, political culture is compatible with rational choice, inasmuch as there is no single standard of rationality, but, rather, it will vary from society to society and era to era. Considerations of the cultural background are necessary to provide content to rational choice theory, since without consideration of culture context rational choice threatens to reduce to a set of colorless banalities.Western studies of China have traditionally focused on Chinese culture (whence the term Sinology-implying that the study of China constituted a science or discipline in its own right). This approach became incorporated into the self-conscious movement toward a scientific method in political science, cresting in the generation following World War II, in the concept of political culture. Sinology assumes that China is sufficiently different from the "west" that it cannot be understood in terms used in the west. The concept of political culture is more universalistic, the product of an ambition to extend the scientific study of politics to the new political systems taking shape in the wake of decolonization. Political culture was especially a feature of modernization theory, a movement reflecting an intellectual interest in how societies change and develop but also more or less explicitly some of the political concerns of Cold War America ([67], 33-34).

How May National Culture Shape Public Policy? The Case of Energy Policy in China

“…Since coming to power, Xi Jinping has emphasized the need to reform the legal system and enhance the role of the courts (Minzner, 2015). Key measures have been to reduce the influence of local governments over local courts by centralizing authority at provincial levels and to build on earlier efforts to professionalize the judiciary (Li, 2016).…”

“…The extent to which today's political culture and political economy represents continuity with the Imperial past or a truly evolutionary new era is contentious (Moody, 2009). Even some of those who argue for a degree of continuity suggest that the CCP has deliberately chosen to wear the imperial mantle of governance rather than unconsciously follow political cultural tradition (Zheng and Huang, 2018).…”

Birth influences future: examining discrimination against Chinese deputy mayors with grassroots administration origins

“…Network-based promotion schools argue that networks are more important than merit in Chinese officials' political promotion. In modern Chinese political research, the network that has been called guanxi (关系) by the Chinese plays an extremely vital role (Dittmer, 1995;Moody, 2009), the princelings' powerful family background has been considered crucial for them to win higher party ranks (Zheng and Fook, 2003;Zheng and Chen, 2009;Zeng, 2013), and the patron-client tie has been mentioned as an essential factor in selecting members of China's supreme decision-making body, the so-called Politburo Standing Committee (Li, 2012a(Li, , 2012b. The main assumption of network-based promotion theories is that Chinese leaders have to select loyal followers to survive fierce factional conflicts or maintain their political influence even in retirement (Pye, 1992;MacFarquhar and Schoenhals, 2006).…”