Politics or Economics? International Migration during the Nicaraguan Contra War

Abstract

The issue of whether Central Americans in the United States are ‘political’ or ‘economic’ migrants has been widely debated, yet little empirical research has informed the controversy. Earlier studies have relied primarily on cross-sectional aggregate data. In order to overcome these limitations we draw on recent surveys conducted in five Nicaraguan communities by the Latin American Migration Project. Using retrospective data, we reconstruct a history of a family's migration to the United States and Costa Rica from the date of household formation to the survey date and link these data to national-level data on GDP and Contra War violence. While out migration to both Costa Rica and the United States is predicted by economic trends, US-bound migration was more strongly linked to the level of Contra War violence independent of economic motivations, especially in an interactive model that allows for a higher wartime effect of social networks. We conclude that elevated rates of Nicaraguan migration to the United States during the late 1980s and early 1990s were a direct result of the US-Contra intervention. The approach deployed here – which relates to the timing of migration decisions to macro-level country trends – enables us to address the issue of political versus economic motivations for migration with more precision than prior work.

America's Immigration Policy Fiasco: Learning from Past Mistakes

“…Although Nicaraguans, escaping a left-wing, pro-Soviet regime, were readily accepted as refugees and ultimately admitted to permanent residence, other Central Americans—Salvadorans, Guatemalans, and Hondurans—were labeled “economic migrants” and not welcomed, with U.S. officials relegating them to temporary protected status at best and more commonly undocumented status, adding a significant central American component to America's Latin American population boom. 24 …”

Twenty-First-Century Globalization and Illegal Migration

“…Although those fleeing Nicaragua were welcomed in the United States as refugees from communist tyranny, refugees from El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras had the misfortune of fleeing right-wing regimes allied with the United States, leading to their label as "economic" rather than "political" migrants (Lundquist and Massey 2005;Massey, Durand, and Pren 2014). As a result, many Central Americans entered without authorization.…”

Justicia transicional y los significados de la elaboración del pasado nicaragüense

“…Cuando la guerra empezó a desacelerarse en el año de la derrota electoral sandinista, una gran parte de la población nicaragüense se vió afectada directamente (Seligson & McElhinny, 1996;Nygren, 2003). La violencia masiva dejó un saldo de aproximadamente 354.000 desplazados internos, y entre 1986 y 1993 se registraron 71.750 refugiados retornados desde los campos costarricenses y hondureños (Dye, Butler, Abu-Lughod & Spence, 1995;Lundquist & Massey, 2005). El proceso masivo de desmovilización dejó decenas de miles de ex-combatientes (contras y miembros del ejército sandinista) en condiciones de vida precarias y de vulnerabilidad socio-económica.…”