Over the past decade,
superhydrophilic zwitterionic surfaces, slippery
liquid-infused porous surfaces, covalently attached liquid-like surfaces,
and superhydrophobic surfaces have emerged as the most promising strategies
to prevent biofouling on biomedical devices. Despite working through
different mechanisms, they have demonstrated superior efficacy in
preventing the adhesion of biomolecules (e.g., proteins and bacteria)
compared with conventional material surfaces. However, their potential
in combating catheter-associated urinary tract infection (CAUTI) remains
uncertain. In this research, we present the fabrication of these four
coatings for urinary catheters and conduct a comparative assessment
of their antifouling properties through a stepwise approach. Notably,
the superhydrophilic zwitterionic coating demonstrated the highest
antifouling activity, reducing 72.3% of fibrinogen deposition and
over 75% of bacterial adhesion (Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus) when compared
with an uncoated polyvinyl chloride (PVC) surface. The zwitterionic
coating also exhibited robust repellence against blood and improved
surface lubricity, decreasing the dynamic coefficient of friction
from 0.63 to 0.35 as compared with the PVC surface. Despite the fact
that the superhydrophilic zwitterionic and hydrophobic liquid-like
surfaces showed great promise in retarding crystalline biofilm formation
in the presence of Proteus mirabilis, it is worth noting that their long-term antifouling efficacy may
be compromised by the proliferation and migration of colonized bacteria
as they are unable to kill them or inhibit their swarming. These findings
underscore both the potential and limitations of these ultralow fouling
materials as urinary catheter coatings for preventing CAUTI.