Although arsenic (As) is recognized as a toxic element for living species, some microorganisms have the ability to tolerate and transform it; recent studies have proposed to take advantage of such capacity to develop sustainable bioremediation strategies. In this study, we evaluated the adaptation to increasing concentrations of As(III) and As(V) of three metabolically different microbial cultures (heterotrophic, autotrophic–acidophilic, and anaerobic) obtained from a sample with low‐soluble As content from the Copahue geothermal system. At the end of the adaptation process, the heterotrophic culture was able to grow at 20 mM and 450 mM of As(III) and As(V), respectively; the autotrophic–acidophilic culture showed tolerance to 15 mM of As(III) and 150 mM of As(V), whereas the anaerobic culture only developed in As(V) at concentrations up to 50 mM. The most tolerant consortia were characterized by their growth performance, complexity, and the presence of genes related to As metabolism and resistance. Regarding the consortia complexity, the predominant genera identified were: Paenibacillus in both heterotrophic consortia, Acidithiobacillus in the autotrophic–acidophilic consortium tolerant to As(III), Acidiphilium in the autotrophic–acidophilic consortium tolerant to As(V), and Thiomonas and Clostridium in the anaerobic consortium. This study is the first report of As tolerance microorganisms obtained from Copahue and reasserts the versatility and flexibility of the community of this natural extreme environment; also, it opens the door to the study of possible uses of these consortia in the design of biotechnological processes where the As concentration may fluctuate.