Power Imbalance and Consumerism in the Doctor-Patient Relationship: Health Care Providers’ Experiences of Patient Encounters in a Rural District in India

Abstract

The aim of this study is to explore health care providers' experiences and perceptions of their encounters with male and female patients in a rural district in India with special reference to tuberculosis (TB) care. The authors conducted semistructured interviews with 22 health care providers, 17 men and 5 women, from the public and private health care sectors. Findings reveal that doctors adopted an authoritarian as well as a consumerist approach in the medical encounter, indicating that power imbalances in the doctor-patient relationship are negotiable and subject to change. Gender was identified as an influencing factor of the doctor's dominance. A patient-centered approach, acknowledging patients' own experiences and shared decision making, is called for and should be included in TB control activities. This seems to be especially important for female patients, whose voices were not heard in the medical encounter.

Effect of informed consent on patients undergoing gastrointestinal surgery and living donor liver transplantation and on their relatives in a developing country

“…For the consent to be valid, the patient must be competent enough to take a decision, should not be under undue stress, and must be presented with true and sufficient information about the intervention4. This appeared to be the case in this study, and demonstrates that in a developing country such as India the informed consent process is there not just for the doctor but also for the patient.…”

“…In a paternalistic society such as India, concerns regarding subordination of the patients' interests to the competing interests of the family also exist. Typically, the decision is guided by the oldest male member of the family, side‐lining the decision of the patient undergoing the intervention, who may be wise and competent enough to make his or her own choice4.…”

Barriers and Facilitators to Family-centred Paediatric Physiotherapy Practice in the Home setting: A Pilot Study

“…This may be due to the power imbalance in the medical decision-making process, and further reinforces the need for shared decision-making among healthcare providers (Fochsen et al, 2006).…”

How patients navigate the diagnostic ecosystem in a fragmented health system: a qualitative study from India

“…As noted by Barbot [35, p. 539], ‘providers expect patients “to co-operate” in order to acquire the cognitive and moral references of their medical environment, and thereby usefully participate in their own therapy’ [35]. A study on medical encounters in TB care in India showed that healthcare providers adopted an authoritarian approach to persuade ‘the ignorant patient’ to follow their advice [36]. Therefore, building a trust-based relationship between providers and patients through taking the time to explain and communicate the different aspects of diagnostic tests, procedures and possible diseases is vital in making sure that patients follow the advice to undergo tests.…”