The flooding record of North America has been used to infer patterns of global erosion and sea level in deep time. Here, we utilize the geospatial dimension of the stratigraphic record provided by the Macrostrat database, and patterns of erosion from thermochronology, to resolve local tectonic subsidence from global sea level. We show that the flooding history of North America correlates in space and time with continent-facing subduction along active margins, consistent with subduction-driven dynamic topographic subsidence of the continental interior. Nonetheless, the continentally aggregated flooding signal of North America is an exaggerated global M-curve of Phanerozoic sea level. This coincidence relates to the closing of the geodynamic loop of the supercontinent cycle: Subduction under North America accommodated both the makeup and breakup of Pangaea, which, coupled with changing ridge length, flattened hypsometry, and increased sea level both locally and globally. The sole Phanerozoic exception to this pattern of global sea level tracking North American near-field geodynamics is the Cambrian Sauk transgression. We argue that this is a far-field record of the inception of circum-Gondwanan subduction, independent of North America, which significantly flattened Earth’s hypsometry. This hypsometric flattening displaced ocean water globally, flooding tectonically passive North America to seal the Great Unconformity.