Predicting Firm Financial Distress: A Mixed Logit Model

Abstract

Over the past three decades the literature on financial distress prediction has largely been confined to simple multiple discriminant analysis, binary logistic or probit analysis, or rudimentary multinomial logit models (MNL). There has been a conspicuous absence of modeling innovation in this literature as well as a failure to keep abreast of important methodological developments emerging in other fields of the social sciences. In particular, there has been no recognition of major advances in discrete choice modeling over the last 15 years, which has increasingly relaxed behaviorally questionable assumptions associated with the independently and identically distributed errors (IID) condition and allowed for observed and unobserved heterogeneity. In contrast to standard logit, the mixed logit model fulfils this purpose and provides a superior framework for explanation and prediction. We explain the theoretical and econometric underpinnings of mixed logit and demonstrate its empirical usefulness in the context of a specific but topical area of accounting research: financial distress prediction. Comparisons of model-fits and out-of-sample forecasts indicate that mixed logit outperforms standard logit by significant margins. While mixed logit has valuable applications in financial distress research, its potential usefulness in other areas of accounting research should not be overlooked.

Financial Distress of Local Government : A Study on Local Government Characteristics, Infrastructure, and Financial Condition

“…Due to the financial and market data for these companies it is available and easily accessible. In this context, 'distress' has been widely interpreted as an event which is according to creditors takes place as a result of administrative problems (bankruptcy), default of credit payment, failure to pay dividend for preferred stocks (or even the decrease in the payment of dividend for common stocks), the problem of preferred dividend to fulfil the deficiencies of working capital, financial reorganization where debts were converted to be equity, and payments to pay listing cost (Bahnson & Bartley, 1992;Foster, 1986;Jones & Hensher, 2004;Lau, 1987;Ward, 1994).…”

Las etapas del ciclo de vida de la empresa por los patrones del estado de flujo de efectivo y el riesgo de insolvencia empresarial

“…El estudio de Caro, Díaz y Porporato (2013) replica el modelo Jones y Hensher (2004): utilizan el modelo logístico mixto para predecir el riesgo de crisis en el período 1993-2000 con estados contables de empresas argentinas. Los resultados indican que los ratios más importantes en cuanto a capacidad discriminatoria son los que miden rentabilidad, rotación del activo y endeudamiento de la empresa.…”

Factores determinantes para predecir la crisis financiera en empresas argentinas

“…Debido a la disponibilidad de los balances de varios períodos para cada empresa, en la década del 2000 se aplicaron los denominados modelos mixtos para predecir la crisis financiera, en economías desarrolladas (Jones y Hensher, 2004). Caro, et al (2013) estiman un modelo de riesgo de una economía emergente, como es Argentina, para la década de 1990.…”