Preliminary evidence that acute stress moderates basal testosterone's association with retaliatory behavior

Abstract

A contribution to a special issue on Hormones and Human Competition. Testosterone is theorized to increase retaliation after social provocation. However, empirical evidence in support of these theories is mixed. The present research investigated whether acute stress causally suppresses testosterone's association with retaliation. We also explored sex differences in behavioral responses to acute stress. Thirty-nine participants (51.28% male) were randomly assigned to a high- or low-stress condition. Then participants engaged in 20 one-shot rounds of the ultimatum game, which was used to assess retaliatory behavioral responses to unfair treatment. Participants provided two saliva samples to measure testosterone and cortisol concentrations - one sample before the stress manipulation, and the second after the ultimatum game (20minutes post-stressor). Results revealed a positive association between basal testosterone and retaliation in the low-stress condition, but not in the high-stress condition. Further, cortisol concentrations increased in the high- compared to the low-stress condition, and these cortisol changes moderated the association between basal testosterone and retaliation. The associations between basal testosterone and retaliation under varying levels of stress were similar in men and women. However, there was a sex difference in behavioral responses to the stress manipulation that was independent of testosterone. In women, the high-stress condition reduced retaliation compared to the low-stress condition, whereas in men the opposite pattern emerged. Collectively, this study (i) provides preliminary evidence that experimentally manipulated stress blocks basal testosterone's association with retaliation, and (ii) reveals a sex difference in retaliation under varying levels of stress. Discussion focuses on mechanisms, limitations, and the need for follow-up studies with larger sample sizes.

Aggression in Women: Behavior, Brain and Hormones

“…Despite these mean differences, the authors found positive correlations between testosterone and self-reported aggression in both women and men. Thus, although aggression and testosterone may be lower in women than men, many studies observed the same positive relationships between testosterone and aggression in women as they do in men (e.g., Prasad et al, 2017 ; Probst et al, 2018 ). A study of 12 women in a double-blind placebo-controlled testosterone administration study suggests that testosterone may increase aggression because it reduces sensitivity to punishment and increases reward sensitivity (van Honk et al, 2004 ).…”

The Causal Effect of Testosterone on Men’s Competitive Behavior is Moderated by Basal Cortisol and Cues to an Opponent’s Status: Evidence for a Context-Dependent Dual Hormone Hypothesis

“…Future work interested in examining testosterone treatment's interaction with cortisol change dynamics as predictors of competitive decision-making will require study designs that measure or manipulate acute cortisol change prior to a competitive decision-making task (e.g. Prasad et al, 2017).…”

Prosocial Behavior and Depression: a Case for Developmental Gender Differences

“…However, if the prosocial behavior is directed at someone belonging to the participant’s in-group (e.g., a friend), higher testosterone is associated with more cooperative behavior in males [84, 91, 92]. In women, the link between testosterone and prosocial behavior is mixed, with studies reporting a negative association [93], in one case following mild stress [87] and a positive association [93, 94], in one case only when reciprocating generosity [93]. Although the association between testosterone in prosocial behavior per se has not been studied across adolescence, there is a positive relationship between testosterone and antisocial behavior that intensifies across adolescence in males, but not females, which may be informed by social experiences and higher fetal exposure to testosterone [95].…”