“…Therefore, the preparation of Mn-doped Ti n O 2n−1 via H 2 reduction of TiO 2 are infeasible notwithstanding other preparations such as metallothermic reduction. Rule 2 is observed for other reported dopants of Ti n O 2n−1 : C, 22 N, 19,21 Cu, 17 Y, 26 Zr, 22 Nb, 18,24,26,27 Mo, 26 Ta, 27 and Ce. 20 However, they violate rules 1 (C, N, and Mo) and 3 (C IV , N III , and Cu III low-spin complex, Y III , Zr IV , Ce III , and Ce IV ), or there is insufficient data to evaluate rule 4 (all but Zr IV ).…”