We report on measurements of visible extinction spectra of semicontinuous silver nanoshells grown on colloidal silica spheres. We find that thin, fractal shells below the percolation threshold exhibit geometrically tunable plasmon resonances. A modified scaling theory approach is used to model the dielectric response of such shells, which is then utilized to obtain the extinction cross section in a retarded Mie scattering formalism. We show that such spherical resonators support unique plasmon dynamics: in the visible there is a new regime of coherently driven cluster-localized plasmons, while crossover to homogeneous response in the infrared predicts a delocalized shell plasmon.Noble-metal nano-scale shells are comprised of thin gold or silver films surrounding sub-micron dielectric cores. In recent years nanometer-scale metal particles have been the focus of extensive studies, owing mainly to large enhancements of surface-induced electric fields at the plasma resonance of the nanoparticles [1]. This unique optical response is well exemplified in the nanoshells' extinction spectra, which are governed by a geometrically tunable plasmon resonance. When the core diameter is in the sub-micrometer range, the optical response of the composite particle is tunable over the entire visible and near infrared spectrum [2]. This constitutes a powerful tool for custom-designing Raman [3] and surface-plasmon-based ultra sensitive optical sensors [4].The strong optical resonance observed in spherical nanoshells is attributed to a delocalized shell plasmon, typically well-modelled by classical linear response to electromagnetic (EM) plane-wave scattering [5]. This was formulated by Aden and Kerker (AK) [6] as an extension to classical Mie scattering theory. More refined theories utilizing ab-initio quantum mechanical modelling of metallic nanoshells have also verified this approach [7].The existence of a spherical-shell plasmon relies on a symmetric and uniform shell morphology, and is typically observed in smooth, continuous nanoshells. It has been previously shown that extinction spectra of incomplete, highly fragmented nanoshells do not exhibit geometrical resonances [8], but are dominated instead by absorption resonances of the metal clusters on the spheres [9].In this Letter we present light scattering experiments of silica spheres coated with discontinuous silver nanoshells. We distinguish two shell morphologies with differing optical signatures. For thin, two-dimensional (2D) fractal shells, the optical response of the metal is best described within the framework of percolation theory. While these shells support mainly localized plasmon modes and are electrically insulating, distinct geometrical resonances are clearly present, due to coherent optical driving of cluster-localized plasmons. For thick (3D), conducting and porous shells classical, Maxwell Garnett (MG) theory is used instead to obtain the effective dielectric response of the shell. In both cases, although the shells are locally highly irregular, observed fine...