“…I was invited to write this article because of my place within the power structure of literacy teacher education, a status I have cultivated over many decades of work. My positioning includes conducting a study of English education methods course syllabi (Smagorinsky & Whiting, 1995); editing a volume updating that work in light of field-wide developments over the span of two decades (Pasternak, Caughlan, Hallman, Renzi, & Rush, 2018); studying a range of beginning teachers through the Center on Learning and Achievement (e.g., Smagorinsky & Barnes, 2014); producing materials for teaching pedagogical methods in teacher education courses (e.g., Smagorinsky, 2018a); conducting current longitudinal research following teachers since 2010 as their careers unfold across multiple contexts (e.g., Smagorinsky, 2018b);teaching initial certification courses for three decades; participating in a wide range of educational summits and the publications they produced (Dickson & Smagorinsky, 2006); developing and teaching in pedagogical programs in the United States and in Guadalajara, Mexico; and engaging in many more teacher education activities than space limitations make advisable to list any further.…”