Procedures as dialogical sequences: A revised version of the fundamental concept in cognitive analytic therapy

Abstract

Problematic action patterns that patients are unable to abandon or modify are important treatment targets in cognitive analytic therapy. They are called procedural sequences in the conceptual model underlying the approach. Interpersonal events in the patients' lives, and in the consulting room as well, frequently display such patterns. They are called reciprocal role procedures. In the present paper the sequential description of problem procedures will be examined by using Bakhtin's dialogical understanding of mental phenomena. A restatement of the original concept will be presented with the aim of integrating the sequential and reciprocal aspects of problematic action patterns. The revised concept of dialogical sequences will be illustrated by a number of case vignettes. The analysis of dialogical sequences provides a clear conceptual basis for early description of problem procedures in therapy. It also provides an effective tool for a detailed supervision of therapy sessions. Finally, dialogical sequence analysis may be used as a psychotherapy process research method to examine the interpersonal patterns in patient narratives.

Insecure attachment states: their relationship to borderline and narcissistic personality disorders and treatment process in cognitive analytic therapy

“…However, Neville Symington's (1993) influential book on narcissism shows some rapprochement between psychoanalytic and attachment theories. Symington shares with Ryle and with Leiman (1997) a dialogic view of the self, as inherently relational. He sees narcissism as a 'chosen' response to trauma in relationships (i.e.…”

Rewriting Self-Narratives: The Therapeutic Process

“…For example, one who has undergone a severe loss adopts a new vision of the world after a dark period (Neimeyer, 2000). Even the dialogical relationship between the characters representing the various aspects of the self gets transformed (Hermans, 1996a, b;Hermans & Hermans-Jansen, 1995;Leiman, 1997;Leiman & Stiles, 2001). Characters that were in the shadows move into the spotlight and say what they have to say.…”

Therapeutic collaboration and resistance: Describing the nature and quality of the therapeutic relationship within ambivalence events using the Therapeutic Collaboration Coding System

“…Theoretically, voices are constructed from the traces of the person's experiences, including experiences passed to them though other people by signs and stories (Stiles, 2011). Each voice is agentic and possesses its own characteristics and ways of being in the world (Hermans, 1996(Hermans, , 2001a(Hermans, , 2001bHermans & Dimaggio, 2007;Hermans & Kempen, 1993;Leiman, 1997Leiman, , 2002Osatuke et al, 2004). Insofar as the self is composed of voices, each utterance or action by a person is the action of some internal voice or the coordinated action of several voices.…”