Controlling
DNA adsorption on nanomaterials is crucial for a wide
range of applications in analytical and biomedical sciences. Polydopamine
(PDA) is a versatile material that can be coated on nearly any surface,
and thus adsorbing DNA onto PDA can be a general method for indirect
DNA functionalization of surfaces. Polyvalent metal ions were reported
to promote DNA adsorption on PDA nanoparticles (NPs), but previous
works added the metal ions after the formation of PDA. Herein, we
compared the effect of polyvalent metal ions added during the synthesis
of PDA NPs (called metal-doped) with the effect of polyvalent metal
ions added after the synthesis (metal-adsorbed). A series of metal
ions including Ca2+, Zn2+, Ni2+,
Fe3+, and Gd3+ were tested, and Zn2+ was studied in detail due to its excellent ability for promoting
DNA adsorption. With 100 μM Zn2+, metal-doped NPs
were ∼30% more efficient than metal-adsorbed NPs for DNA adsorption
in buffer attributable to a higher metal loading on the surface of
the metal-doped NPs. Metal leaching was negligible from the metal-doped
NPs, and they showed a remarkably higher robustness than the metal-adsorbed
NPs, resulting in a 20-fold higher DNA extraction efficiency from
serum. Based on the desorption studies, a higher adsorption affinity
for the metal-doped NPs was confirmed. Finally, the Zn2+-doped PDA NPs were used for sensitive DNA detection with a limit
of detection of 0.45 nM, and the sensor was highly resistant to nonspecific
protein and phosphate displacement.