Promoting Intellectual Discovery: Patents Versus Markets

Abstract

Because they provide exclusive property rights, patents are generally considered to be an effective way to promote intellectual discovery. Here, we propose a different compensation scheme, in which everyone holds shares in the components of potential discoveries and can trade those shares in an anonymous market. In it, incentives to invent are indirect, through changes in share prices. In a series of experiments, we used the knapsack problem (in which participants have to determine the most valuable subset of objects that can fit in a knapsack of fixed volume) as a typical representation of intellectual discovery problems. We found that our "markets system" performed better than the patent system.

From behavioural economics to neuroeconomics to decision neuroscience: the ascent of biology in research on human decision making

“…Unfortunately, constrained optimisation often presupposes cognitive capabilities that contradict the bounded rationality that underlies satisficing behaviour. Indeed, constrained optimisation problems may be very 'hard' [12]. Still, this is not a concern for traditional economics, where the agent would choose merely 'as if' implementing constrained optimisation.…”

Collective Problem-Solving: The Role of Self-Efficacy, Skill, and Prior Knowledge

“…The Burglar problem is an intellective task, which has a demonstrable correct solution, but this solution is difficult to verify. As demonstrated by Meloso, Copic, and Bossaerts (2009), the complexity of the problem can be controlled by generating instances of the Burglar problem at various levels of complexity. The naïve framing of the problem, however, is easy to comprehend.…”

Laboratory experiments in innovation research: a methodological overview and a review of the current literature

“…The respective entrepreneurs subsequently profit substantially from the protection, as well as generating wealth without intellectual property protection. Meloso et al (2009) use another kind of search task-namely the knapsack problem-to simulate intellectual discovery in a patent and a non-patent market system, in which components of potential discoveries are traded. The goal of the knapsack problem is to combine inputs of a particular value and realize an optimal weighing of the components.…”