The in vitro wear of articular cartilage in oscillating and impulsively loaded bovine metatarsophalangeal joints was studied. Articular cartilage scarification had little effect on cartilage wear, but stiffening of the subchondral bone with methyl methacrylate greatly increased the rate of cartilage loss, whether or not it had previously been scarified. Glutaraldehyde treatment of articular cartilage for 30 minutes decreased its wear rate. Guanidinium chloride extraction of the cartilage before wear testing caused it to peel off its subchondral bed. This effect could be spared by prior glutaraldehyde fixation.In vivo cartilage fibrillation has been presumed to be one of the first stages of a process that eventually leads to a total loss of cartilage substance, the exposure of the bony subchondral plate, and, finally, an articular surface made up of eburnated bone (1). However, Byers et a1 (2) necessarily progressive, and Bullough et a1 (4) have suggested that the loading characteristics within the joint are important determinants of the pattern of articular cartilage loss. It has also been established that relative stiffness of the underlying subchondral bone plays an important role in determining the behavior of its overlying cartilage (5).Oscillating joints can be worn out in vitro by being subjected to repetitive impulsive loads superimposed upon a static one (6). We previously reported preliminary experiments in which bovine metatarsophalangeal articular cartilage was subjected to glutaraldehyde fixation and wear tested in vitro (7). In these inital tests, we found that glutaraldehyde increased the stiffness of the cartilage and apparently the in vitro cartilage wear as well. In contrast to this, studies by Lipshitz et a1 (8), which used another in vitro wear method in which they rubbed cartilage plugs on glass under static load, showed that formaldehyde fixation decreased cartilage wear. With this new information in mind, we undertook a new series of experiments for 2 reasons: 1) to restudy the effect of glutaraldehyde fixation of articular cartilage on the in vitro wear rate of articular cartilage, and 2) to study the effects of proteoglycan loss, subchondral bone stiffening, and scarification of cartilage as well as the role of synovial fluid on cartilage wear.
MATERIALS AND METHODSMetatarsophalangeal joints of adult cows were obtained at the slaughter house and frozen. Such treatment does not affect the mechanical or chemical properties of these tissues (6). When needed, paired joints from each animal were thawed, dissected free of all soft tissue, mounted with methyl methacrylate in metal holders, and subjected